I will go by the active player rule in no particular order:
Joe Thomas, thank you Browns FO for wasting this once in a lifetime career
Klubot, very underappreciated outside of Cleveland fans imo. He also got screwed out of being a 3x CYA winner.
Larry Fitz, been a fan since his college days. Just a class act all around and I appreciate his consistency with age.
Gianluigi Buffon, I'd have Pirlo here, but he recently retired.
Kyle Snyder, quietly becomming one of the greatest wrestlers in US history and possibly the world.