posted by like_that
The coping of Biden’s failure is sad and pathetic. If the best you can do is bring up Trump to defend Biden, then it’s not really a strong argument, especially when Biden played a big part of this 20 year shit show prior to taking office. I am not surprised to see certain people pretend he just inherited this mess though.
It’s ok to admit the Biden Administration completely failed with this withdrawal. Anyone who actually paid attention to the Biden campaign is not shocked by how these events took place. They literally ran on “we are not Trump,” and hid from the public for the majority of the time. That’s pretty much how this administration ran for Biden’s first 7 months in office as well, until all of this erupted. They weren’t meant to be in the spotlight making tough decisions and answering (for once) tough questions. This past month has done nothing, but confirm it. They are just not good at this job. Biden’s grade as a commander in chief is currently a F. Hopefully he improves that grade in the next 3.5 years considering lives will be on the line.
This is by no means an endorsement for Trump. He should have withdrawn during his 4 years, but he played politics with the withdrawal. I naively thought TDS would go away with Trump gone, but it looks like some people need therapy to let it go.
I get some of that and you may be right. I also understand that no administration would have done this correctly. Biden's actions were pretty bad, but this is just the latest in line with strategic surprises and failures. It is amazing how little we learn from our past mistakes. The writing was on the wall from human rights groups, the State Department and Afghan translators.
I do agree that Biden does deserve a good amount of blame for his Obama time in office. But, if you go back and read the decision making in the time for the surge in 09-10, Biden was one of the ones saying we need to get out and was against the surge of troops. Gates and Clinton were in favor of the surge and they won the argument.
I think the big thing to blame Biden on is his inability to adapt to the situation. He made the decision to get out. He did not listen to any earlier guidance from generals, State, or Afghans saying hey, speed up the withdraw of people here. It seems he was one track focused, getting out. It seems like he looked at the generals and other people around the room and said, their advice has been wrong for 20 years, why should I listen to it now? That single focus on ignoring things until it below up in our face, and the failure to see the collpase coming is what made this mess.