Ohio Chatter

Quarterbacks

Sports
Ironman92 Administrator
56,729 posts 168 reps Joined Nov 2009
Tue, Sep 24, 2019 6:04 PM

I usually do a Top 10 NFL QB thread...as I got thinking I’m not sure there are 10 that are still really good. A few years ago it seemed as if it were 15 strong.

Brees, Manning, Luck, Roethlisberger out....Rodgers isn’t what he was. Newton has been bad. Rivers slipping some. Stafford/Ryan not as good. Wentz/Goff aren’t looking great.

 

Is the worst Top 10 QB’s basically now right before our eyes?

Mahomes

Brady

Wilson

Prescott

Rodgers?

Watson?

Garappolo

Jackson?

Wentz? Goff?

Rivers

friendfromlowry Senior Member
7,778 posts 87 reps Joined Nov 2009
Wed, Sep 25, 2019 12:09 PM

1. Patrick Mahomes

2. Tom Brady

3. Drew Brees

4. Aaron Rodgers

5. Dak Prescott

6. Phillip Rivers

7. Deshaun Watson

8. Matt Ryan

9. Russell Wilson

10. Carson Wentz
BR1986FB Senior Member
27,923 posts 126 reps Joined Feb 2010
Wed, Sep 25, 2019 12:17 PM

What killed me was Troy Aikman's comments about Pat Mahomes. Aikman, along with Terry Bradshaw & Joe Namath are the worst QB's (statistically) to be in the HOF.
Ironman92 Administrator
56,729 posts 168 reps Joined Nov 2009
Wed, Sep 25, 2019 12:32 PM
posted by friendfromlowry

1. Patrick Mahomes

2. Tom Brady

3. Drew Brees

4. Aaron Rodgers

5. Dak Prescott

6. Phillip Rivers

7. Deshaun Watson

8. Matt Ryan

9. Russell Wilson

10. Carson Wentz

Looks good but also, Brees out, Rodgers doesn’t seem as good, Ryan has great receivers but still already 6 interception.

Just not a strong top 10 IMO
Heretic Son of the Sun
20,517 posts 204 reps Joined Nov 2009
Wed, Sep 25, 2019 12:43 PM

I'd have to put some thought and research into things, but, yeah, a world where Matt Ryan of 2019 might be a Top 10 guy is about as bad as things could get.
Laley23 GOAT
33,369 posts 133 reps Joined Nov 2009
Wed, Sep 25, 2019 2:01 PM

The QB situation in the league is really bad, and it was really good not too long ago. 

  1. Mahomes
  2. Brady
  3. Wilson
  4. Watson
  5. Rodgers
  6. Dak 
  7. Rivers
  8. Goff
  9. Wentz
  10. Josh Allen

Honestly 8-10 you could convince me of the 3 I listed, Brisett, Ryan or Garappolo. I omitted anyone injured.
justincredible Honorable Admin
37,969 posts 250 reps Joined Nov 2009
Wed, Sep 25, 2019 2:25 PM

Christ. When Josh Allen and Jacoby Brisett are cracking top 10 QB lists you know it's dire.
Ironman92 Administrator
56,729 posts 168 reps Joined Nov 2009
Wed, Sep 25, 2019 9:43 PM
posted by Laley23

The QB situation in the league is really bad, and it was really good not too long ago. 

  1. Mahomes
  2. Brady
  3. Wilson
  4. Watson
  5. Rodgers
  6. Dak 
  7. Rivers
  8. Goff
  9. Wentz
  10. Josh Allen

Honestly 8-10 you could convince me of the 3 I listed, Brisett, Ryan or Garappolo. I omitted anyone injured.

Probably about the one I agree with the most. I’d probably have Garappolo in the 8-10 spot with Allen on the outside but 🤷🏻‍♂️
friendfromlowry Senior Member
7,778 posts 87 reps Joined Nov 2009
Wed, Sep 25, 2019 10:44 PM

It'd be interesting to redo this debate at the end of the year, to see if any of the young guys have convinced us they should be in the list. Minshew, Kyle Allen, Mason Rudolph, Baker, Lamar Jackson, Kyler Murray, Daniel Jones, Brissett, Trubisky maybe. 
Laley23 GOAT
33,369 posts 133 reps Joined Nov 2009
Thu, Sep 26, 2019 8:39 AM
posted by friendfromlowry

It'd be interesting to redo this debate at the end of the year, to see if any of the young guys have convinced us they should be in the list. Minshew, Kyle Allen, Mason Rudolph, Baker, Lamar Jackson, Kyler Murray, Daniel Jones, Brissett, Trubisky maybe. 

Trubisky might be worse than half the backups in the NFL. So, no, he won’t be making any top 10 lists lol.
like_that 1st Team All-PWN
29,228 posts 321 reps Joined Apr 2010
Thu, Sep 26, 2019 3:56 PM

Baker currently not being able to crack into these lists is depressing.
Ironman92 Administrator
56,729 posts 168 reps Joined Nov 2009
Thu, Sep 26, 2019 5:04 PM
posted by like_that

Baker currently not being able to crack into these lists is depressing.

I had him pegged in at about #9 going into the season. Surprised of his play so far. Doesn’t seem like very often he progresses past the first option and then veers his way to make something happen....but it’s not been happening this year.
Ironman92 Administrator
56,729 posts 168 reps Joined Nov 2009
Thu, Sep 26, 2019 5:05 PM

It wasn’t long ago that peak and awesome Phillip Rivers was like #6 and now old and a bit of a shell of himself Rivers is #5

Login

Forgot Your Password?

Register

Already have an account? Login