posted by O-TrapFor the record, these are all just years active at all. If someone had 5 at-bats in a season, that would qualify, but it qualifies for all candidates.
The third winner still had over 8000 at-bats and is in the HOF, so it's not a Deion Sanders-type answer.
Hey! That was a good question to keep everyone on their toes and thinking outside the box