enigmaax;560922 wrote:If found guilty, protocol would certainly call for Auburn to vacate wins. However, I don't think the NCAA is going to go that route, especially if they do make a ruling before the end of this season. The gray areas being that he may not have actually taken money and he may not have actually known about it and that Auburn may not have had anything to do with it. So a great way to punish him yet not cause a huge stain on the on-going season is to simply suspend him and move on. It is a complete guess on my part and I've been wrong before...I just don't think they'll be vacating anything (unless the ruling comes after the season, in which case there isn't much else that could be done).
In a lot of way this case is somewhat similar to the situation that got Jim O'Brian fired. O'Brian gave $3,000 to a recruit that didn't even come to Ohio State. It had no effect on any games played by Ohio State as he was never on the team, yet OSU had to vacate an entire season of wins, give back a Big Ten championship trophy, and remove 1998 from their Final Four banner. Here we have a situation where someone asked for upwards of $200,000 from a school, didn't get it, and went elsewhere. If Newton never received any money and if Auburn never knew about any of this then his current school never broke any rules and he never broke any while there, yet they would still be held liable. Precedent tells me that wins would be vacated. Also, with as hard as the NCAA came down on USC basically making an example out of them, I highly doubt that they would go easy on this situation.
Part of the problem that this will take long is because the NCAA usually doesn't look at things unless a school self-reports, and while MSU did report, no one really self-reported. The reason that things like the agent scandal early in the year with UNC went quickly was because the school self-reported and because everyone pretty much confessed. If Cecil Newton really has confessed then this should be easy to close, determine punishment, and move on. If Auburn plays in the National Championship with Newton and he's later declare ineligible then the title is vacated if they won, and if they lost there will always be questions as to whether or not Oregon would have beaten Boise or TCU or whoever would have benefited from Auburn being held out of the title game.