krambman;565331 wrote:The NCAA will never give out the death penalty again. Florida State had cheating on nearly every sports team organized by the academic liaison staff and didn't get the death penalty. USC had major violations in at least three sports all at once and didn't get the death penalty. Those cases showed a clear lack of institutional control, which is necessary for the death penalty and neither school got anything close to it. The death penalty not only set the SMU athletic department back 30+ years but it nearly bankrupted the school. The NCAA had no clue about the kind of economic impact that it would have. Now that they do they will never give it out again.
Agree with this, though I don't know why the NCAA is so uneasy about the SMU thing. It is punishment...it isn't supposed to be fun. If they didn't want their program set back 30 years, they shouldn't have kept the slush fund AFTER the NCAA busted them the first 10 times. Additionally, note that the NCAA banned SMU for one year and SMU added another year to that itself.
That is another big difference between SMU and a lot of these cases that people either don't know or don't remember. Lack of institutional control is completely different than the institution being directly involved. In SMU's case, the Board of Governors and people in the Athletic Department were directly involved...including continuing payments despite already being on probation for that very thing. As I recall, they felt they had to "honor" their commitments to the players they already promised to pay. The death penalty was mostly about being repeat offenders and I think there was a time window originally established (like being busted for major violations twice within five years).
Technically, the NCAA has the right to enact that penalty for more severe actions though I don't know that is really spelled out. I believe that the NCAA has actually handed this punishment out 2 or 3 times since the SMU penalty, but I don't think it was for football and obviously not at the DI or FBS level (just can't remember off the top of my head - and I could be wrong).
Oh and, Kentucky basketball kind of had the death penalty in the 50s. They bounced back nicely.