Of course Pettine would have loved to stick with hoyer, they were fucking winning and he was playing well.
The last thing a team wants to do when drafting a QB in the first round is get them beat up mentally and shake their confidence. So much about the NFL comes from confidence, and I think this was handled very well.
Both of these.
At some point, the organization was going to go to Manziel unless Hoyer became the second coming of Tom Brady. There is plenty of history to suggest that rookie QBs that get thrown right into the fire get eaten alive or hurt or damaged. The Browns and Pettine have played it well. They ran with Hoyer and won, while JFF got his feet wet, learned the pro game and what was expected. Now it's time to see what he's got, especially since Hoyer has not been playing well.
I have nothing bad to say about Hoyer...he is what he is. I have no doubt that he has given his best effort, and I appreciate that he has confidence in his own abilities, even in the face of the adversity of the past few weeks. Any pro QB that didn't believe he was the "best" option, or believe in himself isn't an NFL QB.... period. I have no problem with Hoyer thinking that he still is as long as he accepts the role that the coach has given him.
Pettine has had a great first year as a coach. I think he still has a lot to learn especially with in game mangement, just as I think JFF will also have some learning to do. Pettine has handled the QB pretty admirably. The only thing where I think he screwed up was not getting Manziel in there last week, at least for a few series....and by that failure, cost the team a much needed win. There's no way that I can prove that...JMHO. All in all, he's done a great job coaching these guys "up".