The 11 best bargains, and the 11 worst contracts in the NFL - NFL - CBSSports.com News, Rumors, Scores, Stats, Fantasy
http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/story/19436...acts-in-the-nfl
Best bargains
Aaron Rodgers, Packers, QB, $8.5M: Um, I don't really need to tout this guy's worth, do I? All he has done is quickly make everyone in Green Bay forget about Brett Favre, set historical records, show no fear of the big stage and he already has one Lombardi. I'm on record way back in 2009 as saying, based on age, production, and team-friendly contract, Rodgers was the one person I would pick to start any NFL franchise with, and three years later nothing has changed.
In an era where guys like Sam Bradford make $13.5 million a season and Drew Brees is shooting for $20 million per, Rodgers will earn $8.5 million in 2012 (that's Kevin Kolb money, people). And he's set to earn less than $20 million total in the two remaining years on his deal beyond that, though, I have to believe the Packers will get serious about contract talks with Rodgers after this season.
This is screaming for a renegotiation, with Rodgers' average salary placing him 10th in the NFL among all quarterbacks (behind the likes of Mark Sanchez, whom you will read more about below).
Justin Smith, DE, 49ers, $6.375M: Smith is heading into his third season after redoing his deal, but man if he isn't outperforming it again. He might have been the best defensive player in the NFL last season, and certainly was the central figure in San Francisco's resurgence. Without his wrecking-ball presence, I can't help but wonder if those linebackers would be as effective. Among all defensive ends, Smith stands 12th in average per year, and when Julius Peppers sets the market at this position at $14 million a year, Smith is certainly worth more than half that. He'll cost the 49ers a very manageable $8 million in 2013. Guys like Calais Campbell will pull in $17 million in 2012 alone, including bonuses, and Glenn Dorsey will make more on a cash basis than Smith this season.
Ryan Clady, T, Broncos, $3.5M: An offseason injury imperiled his 2012 season, but the stud left tackle got his game back and overcame it and is in line for a big payday. Of anyone on this list, his new deal could come first, given the import of his position and how underpaid he is as his rookie deal expires. No way you let him get a chance to hit the market being this good and this young, and Mike Shanahan has called him the best left tackle he has seen. Charlie Johnson and Adam Snyder are among those tackles set to make more than Clady in 2012, but, again, I doubt that ends up being the case. A deal could be done by the end of camp, if not sooner.
Joe Flacco, Ravens, QB, $6.76M: He is the subject of much debate, but through four years in the NFL, all he has managed to do is win at least one playoff game every year, he has won four road playoff games already, and he came a Lee Evans drop away from making his first Super Bowl appearance. And when you look at what he's making relative to guys like Sanchez and Bradford, and when you factor in that Flacco's earnings in 2012 put him in line with what stop-gap, end-of-their-career guys like Matt Hasselbeck make, then this is an absolute steal for a young quality starting quarterback. He makes less than Kolb and Matt Flynn in 2012.
Flacco hasn't been surrounded by great talent in the passing game and the offensive line has been iffy at times, but he has won a lot of games and been particularly strong at home. The Ravens would have to franchise him -- if nothing else -- in the future, as talks on a new deal haven't taken off and he's likely to play out this final year of his rookie deal; for a team with Baltimore's cap issues, having the QB count so little against the cap is huge.
Jason Babin, Eagles, DE, $5.75M: Criticize the Eagles and their Dream Team all you like, but everyone except for Nnamdi was signed to very cap-friendly and team-friendly deals. Defensive line coach Jim Washburn knew Babin well from his days at the Titans, and all this guy did was go out and challenge the NFL's single-season sack mark in his first year in Philly. The deal remains very cap-friendly and even in the event of injury, the cap prorations are set up so that the Eagles are protected and the team's cap is in great shape moving forward. Some of those moves from a year ago didn't work so well on the field, but this one certainly did (and Cullen Jenkins' deal is set up similarly as well, and Vince Young was only there for a year, and clearly trading Kevin Kolb made sense, too).
Alex Mack, Browns, C, $2 million: Another stalwart going deeper into his rookie deal, Mack has been an anchor for the offensive line and someone at the heart of what the Browns try to do in the run game and with pass protection. He gets overlooked some because of the team's overall offensive deficiencies, but just as the Browns took care of left tackle Joe Thomas a year ago, so too will Mack be in line for a new deal soon enough.
Mack ranks only 21st in the NFL in average salary for centers (Maurkice Pouncey is right in this area as well, and he's about a year behind Mack in the about-to-get-paid line), and with salaries for interior linemen shooting up big time since Mack entered the league, there is money to be made here. With another new quarterback-of-the-future under center in rookie Brandon Weeden, all the better to secure that QB/C combo for years to come.
Justin Tuck, Giants, DE, $3.85M: For all of the talk about Osi Umenyiora the past few years, and the Giants finally won over that pass rusher by reworking his deal, Tuck is in the same boat. An edge player who makes a huge difference in their pass rushing schemes, Tuck will count only $5.35M against the cap in 2012; another example of the Giants being proactive and getting young talent locked up. However, he's also due only $4.5M in 2013, and with guys like Charles Johnson making $12.7M per year, there will have to be a recalibration here as Tuck nears his turn on the free-agent market (worth noting that John Abraham and Ray Edwards will outearn Tuck in 2012).
Vince Wilfork, Patriots, DT, $5M: I know he is getting older, but is he really slowing down? And is anyone more vital on an erratic Pats defense? He is at the core of everything Bill Belichick does toggling from a 3-4 to a 4-3, and he can still be downright dominating in crucial situations. He allows that defense to survive despite having dynamic young pass rushers off the edge, and yes, you have to factor in the $18 million signing bonus he got in 2010, but still he's a bargain to me. The Pats structured the contract well in case the years do catch up to Wilfork, as he has $15 million in cash due to him between 2013-2014 -- manageable for sure.
Brian Orakpo, Redskins, LB, $1.39M: Washington was desperate for a young edge presence when it took Orakpo in the first round 2009, after flirting with quarterbacks like Mark Sanchez leading up to the draft, and he has delivered. He had a monster rookie season and there is no doubt his presence opened things up for rookie Ryan Kerrigan to shine on the opposite side in 2011. Orakpo could make another $500,000 in escalators in 2012, and in 2013, if he hits all escalators, then he would max out around $4.5M. For a double-digit sack guy, that's about as good of a bargain as you'll find. This is yet another example of how the old rookie system, outside of the first seven or eight picks, still allowed for teams to hit absolute home runs financially if they drafted well. Can't imagine Orakpo actually plays out his rookie deal, however, and the Redskins are willing to spend. And clearly he is a good sport, putting up with whoever was the creative genius behind those Geico commercials.
Brian Waters, Patriots, G, $1.5M: You have to think the Chiefs are kicking themselves for letting him go a year ago. One of the best men in the game and still a strong starting guard for a Super Bowl contender at this stage of his career. The Pats swooped in and signed him late, and he ended up being something of a salvation. And this year, should Waters play at anything close to the level he did in 2011, it's another big victory for the elite franchise. They could bump Waters up a few million based on last year's performance, and he would still be a bargain.
Victor Cruz, Giants, WR, $540,000: I am hesitant to put this one on, because I don't know anyone who expects him to play out his deal and not get better compensated by the time we get through the 2012 season. Cruz came out of nowhere, to not only make the team -- he had flashed at times in the preseason -- but become a true star for the Super Bowl champs. He blossomed into a legit No. 1 receiver and go-to guy for Eli Manning, and after losing Mario Manningham and with Hakeem Nicks injured, his value is tremendous right now.
And now, for the other side of the coin, literally, here are 11 of the more player-friendly contracts in the league: