Azubuike24;1712481 wrote:Better ERA. Not better stats. Last year, Chapman's WHIP, K/9, K/BB were superior. His FIP was way down, which is further reflection that he was prone to just giving up some un-clutch runs (he got beat on walk-offs 3 or 4 times, but was dominant every time else).
I do agree with you though, I was just hypothetically speaking given Chapman's profile is a bit higher. Would you sign him to that?
Regardless, quietly, both of these guys are putting together numbers never seen before in MLB (except a few stretches from Mariano Rivera).
True, THOSE stats for Chapman are better than what Kimbrell did but those arent the end all, be all stats for a closer. Yeah, Chap does it in electric fashion but that isnt what it is all about.
Chap has been the closer for the last three seasons. Take a look at the stats in the last 3 for Kimbrel.
Kimbrel has more saves in each season, LESS blown saves (albeit just by 1) a better ERA which we can argue how important that is, more innings, more appearances than Chapman. Chap really lights it up and is exciting (kimbrel is now slouch either). W-L isnt a good stat for a closer but Kimbrel is 7-7 in the last 3, and chappy is 9-13. ERA can be blown out of proportion for a closer but man, Kimbrel is 1.61, 1.21 and 1.01 the last 3 seasons...that is lights out.
Chapman does it in a more exciting fashion, more dominating, but Kimbrel just may do it more effectively yet not as flashy