Footwedge;1716189 wrote:You and LHShemp can have your 2 man circle jerk. If relief pitching is so much... much ado about nothing than why does Tito have so many of them? Kipnis was absolute dog shit last year and so far...just like last year, he can't stay on the field.
Kipnis..and his ridiculous salary would probably be better served elsewhere. The dp combo of the future does not include him. Laley thinks they are a dime a dozen. LOL. A good relief staff is imperative to win a title.
You have absolutely no knowledge about this. With a few exceptions, who generally are closers, paid more and, therefore, harder to trade for, relievers are a dime a dozen. Their success fluctuates from year to year (which often leads to short MLB careers) and often is determined by the coaching staff getting them in a good position.
Cleveland and Pittsburgh are kind of the same in MLB, both being small-budget teams with a lot of young home-grown talent. I don't know how Cleveland is running their defense, but in Pittsburgh, they're huge into defensive shifts and, as a result, look for relievers who tend to be ground ball pitchers with the idea being to shift a lot to always have guys in position to snare the ground balls. Over the past couple years, these have been their most prominent relievers. A couple have been consistently good, while others (Hughes, Wilson) have followed up good years with weaker ones.
Mark Melancon -- up-and-coming set-up/closer with Houston; went to Boston and bombed; went to Pittsburgh as kind of a reclamation project; did great as a set-up man and has done very good now as the closer.
Jason Grilli -- journeyman middle reliever who'd been most places; because the set-up man and then the closer for Pittsburgh and had a great 2/3 season in that role before an injury sapped his effectiveness.
Vin Mazzaro -- another journeyman-type. He was surprisingly important in 2013 solely because inherited runners never seemed to score on him. Despite that, there was no room for him in the bigs in 2014.
Justin Wilson/Jared Hughes/Tony Watson -- minor league starters converted to major league relievers. The latter is considered to have filthy stuff and possibly is the closer of the future, assuming he doesn't horribly regress since relievers don't always have great shelf life, as I said before.
John Holdzkom -- a late-season revelation last year. Mainly because they found him in some independent league where he'd finally learned to harness his talent enough to get the ball over the plate.
Jeanmar Gomez -- former Tribe guy from a few years back. He did admirably as a long reliever/spot starter.
So, a bullpen that has been considered amongst the league's best over the past two years is construed of a former up-and-comer who'd fallen on hard times supported by a slew of journeymen and minor league starters who had to change their game to get farther than AAA. And no starting-caliber players who'd had success with the team had to be traded to get any of those (although Brock Holt -- part of the Melancon deal -- might be reaching that level post-trade as a "super-utility" guy).