gut;1601305 wrote:
Think about it. Why did they have to go to that specific railcar? If you're just keeping them like cattle, why would it matter? Why even give them their guns back and risk them shooting somoeone?

Unfortunately we don't know enough. was there more than one rail car? maybe they only gave them their guns back because rick's crew got the jump on them(and the Terminus people were unarmed at the time). so instead of taking their guns from people who are obviously very attached to their weapons and creating an situation. they gave them back and gave rick's crew a false sense of security until the Terminus people could get the advantage on them.

There were multiple rail cars, all with people in them. I read that the Terminus leader was giving directions "No, get them away from C....No, not toward A" or something like that. So they wanted them to go to that specific rail car.

As for the guns, Rick & company gave up their weapons willingly. There was no need to give them back, they accepted (and understood) that these people weren't going to welcome in armed strangers. In fact, Rick anticipated doing that which is why he buried extra weapons outside.

gut;1601459 wrote:There were multiple rail cars, all with people in them. I read that the Terminus leader was giving directions "No, get them away from C....No, not toward A" or something like that. So they wanted them to go to that specific rail car.

As for the guns, Rick & company gave up their weapons willingly. There was no need to give them back, they accepted (and understood) that these people weren't going to welcome in armed strangers. In fact, Rick anticipated doing that which is why he buried extra weapons outside.

They didn't exactly give up their guns, they put them on the ground, very much still in arms reach. If Terminus would have told Rick to give up their guns and walk away, no way he would have complied.

what didn't make sense was Rick and them just walking right in. they didn't do very much snooping around first. I would have taken at least a day watching from outside of the fence before going in.

Finally watched the finally and caught up on the thread.

Gut, I understand what you are saying, and may very well be correct...but, I think you might be giving the writers too much credit...THEY SUCK These are the same people who bore us to tears 75% of the time and have this show (literally) walking in circles most of every season. Its the slowest show on TV.

Laley23;1610839 wrote:Finally watched the finally and caught up on the thread.

Gut, I understand what you are saying, and may very well be correct...but, I think you might be giving the writers too much credit...THEY SUCK These are the same people who bore us to tears 75% of the time and have this show (literally) walking in circles most of every season. Its the slowest show on TV.

I agree. I wonder who's vagina will be filled with sand next season. its the zombie apocalypse, suck it up already.

Laley23;1610839 wrote:...but, I think you might be giving the writers too much credit...THEY SUCK

point taken

Glory Days;1601643 wrote: what didn't make sense was Rick and them just walking right in. they didn't do very much snooping around first. I would have taken at least a day watching from outside of the fence before going in.

There's lots of holes in whichever way they go.

Any chance AMC will re-air season 4? I watched first three on Netflix and watch to catch up.

Yes they will.

They do a shit load of marathons when the new season starts.

This weekend. Season 4 starts at 9pm Saturday night.

Sonofanump;1632647 wrote:This weekend. Season 4 starts at 9pm Saturday night.

Thanks for the heads up

Lol, so I just heard that they may make Daryl gay. I guess there's a gay character in the books but instead of bringing in the character, they may just make the most loved character in the show gay. The person who told me said they wouldnt focus on him being gay, so why do it? Smh

bigdaddy2003;1644824 wrote:Lol, so I just heard that they may make Daryl gay. I guess there's a gay character in the books but instead of bringing in the character, they may just make the most loved character in the show gay. The person who told me said they wouldnt focus on him being gay, so why do it? Smh

Given his affection for the butch Carol....maybe he's been gay all along

Just finished watching season 4 on Netflix. I can't believe that little psychopath killed her sister. That was some fucked up shit. The canibal scenario seems most likely but I'm hoping it's something else.

Rotinaj;1659448 wrote:The canibal scenario seems most likely but I'm hoping it's something else.

Why? I think the cannibal scenario will make for a great story-line.

Scarlet_Buckeye;1659597 wrote:Why? I think the cannibal scenario will make for a great story-line.

Because like someone else said earlier in the thread the entire season would be them trying to escape for 15 episodes and a battle for the season finale. If the cannibalism story line were to take half the season I would love it.

Rotinaj;1659607 wrote: If the cannibalism story line were to take half the season I would love it.

I think that's what's more likely to be the case. It will likely take half the season for them to 'get out' and then the 2nd half of the season would likely be building up to the 'next big event' (i.e., next season).

That's how most of the seasons have gone.