vball10set;1152261 wrote:He's a better #2 or #3 IMO--even though Brantley's struggling a bit, he's more suited for the leadoff spot. I'm not a fan of Chris Perez in the closer role either...however, I don't know who we have in the pen that's any better

Kipnis ideal spot is #2. But Id rather him in leadoff than Brantley, who doesnt get on base and is not a threat for anything but singles. Brantley is a low 3rd order guy, imo.
Asdrubal is the teams best #2, and Choo is the 3 hole. Then Santana and Hafner. So Kipnis' only spot is then leadoff. He will help us and do more damage there than at #6. Brantley has had his chance and has essentially sucked for 2.5 years leading off. He is like BARLEY a .300 OBP guy for his career. Thats a pathetic OBP in general, but especially when he is leading off. Coupled with no power or run production and at best equal SB abilities as Kipnis and it makes no sense to bat him leadoff.