I only gave stupid answers. O-Trap gave a stupid question. Ha!

posted by Ironman92

Burks and Castilla also

Is this question over lol?

It might as well be.  Completely blew up in my face.

Here's apparently what we've got:

The triplets in Colorado (which might have made this question cool, if it had asked about three teammates)
Manny and Papi
A-Rod and Palmeiro
Griffey and A-Rod
Griffey and Buhner

posted by justincredible

I only gave stupid answers. O-Trap gave a stupid question. Ha!

I would object, but ...

Question #44

This HOFer has the biggest differential between career games minus career hits.

Most HOFers have more hits than games played

posted by Ironman92

Question #44

This HOFer has the biggest differential between career games minus career hits.

I assume we're excluding pitchers, here.

posted by O-Trap

I assume we're excluding pitchers, here.

Thou shall not assume anything eh Deion?

Gary Carter? Since I was looking at catchers earlier. 

Nolan Ryan

Cy young

Eck

posted by Ironman92

Thou shall not assume anything eh Deion?

LOL  I guess that one played in my favor.

Rivera

Oh yeah, a reliever would make more sense than a starter.

Mo Rivera

posted by Al Bundy

Rivera

I came back here to guess this.  Pitched for a long time.  Appeared in a ton of games, but always in short stints.  Has to be him.  The differential might be in the thousands.

posted by Al Bundy

Rivera

1115 games, zero hits

Eck was 2nd

Lee Smith close too

4 career plate appearances.

posted by justincredible

4 career plate appearances.

Poor managing clearly

Now I wonder what the answer is without pitchers.

posted by Ironman92

Same here man. The greatest player in the game and an electric player coming to play in his hometown Cincy .....ended up too good to be true or just a big bad luck jinx of injuries

Even as an Indians fan, I still believe Griffey was probably the best all around player since at least Willie Mays, if not all time.

Speed, defense in CF, hit for average, and hit for power. 

He would have put the HR record beyond Bonds' reach if not for injuries.

posted by Laley23

Now I wonder what the answer is without pitchers.

Don’t!!! I’m researching for later!

baseball reference is really slow lol we are killing it

posted by Ironman92

Don’t!!! I’m researching for later!

baseball reference is really slow lol we are killing it

Don't bother. I already know.  ;)  (Came across it while doing the same thing)

Question #45:

Between 1990 and 2010, four non-HOF players won the Silver Slugger award and the MVP in the same year year, despite having starting teammates with: more HRs, fewer SOs, a better slugging percentage, and a better on-base percentage.

Name them.

(I researched the hell out of this one to make sure it didn't turn into another dumpster fire question)

Jeff kent

posted by O-Trap

Don't bother. I already know.  ;)  (Came across it while doing the same thing)

It’s question 46 and I added to it...but first yours

Gallaraga?

Edit: didn’t win