10 active players have between 250-299 career HR…..many have been top 5 MVP 3+ times. Name the only player to have 250-299 career HR but has never been a top 5 MVP…and also name the player with only 1 top 5

Anthony Rizzo.

Jayson Heyward.

2 complete stabs in the dark without much thought.

Evan Longoria, Justin Upton (is he even active??), Josh Donaldson, Carlos Santana. 

posted by Laley23

Anthony Rizzo.

Jayson Heyward.

2 complete stabs in the dark without much thought.

Rizzo was top 5 2x (I think 4th both times)…..Heyward not in that range of HR

Heyward 159 career HR!

Losers

posted by Ironman92

Losers

Santana isn’t. Just looked him up. 

posted by Laley23

Evan Longoria, Justin Upton (is he even active??), Josh Donaldson, Carlos Santana. 

Donaldson 2 or 3x top 5, Longoria above the range but no top 5 I don’t think. Upton same.

Santana is the 0….he’s never been top 5.

Still need the player only a 1x top 5

JD Martinez? I feel he has never been top-5 MVP, so likely has 300+ HRs.  It I’m out of guesses for that range.

Harper and Manny both too good.

posted by Laley23

JD Martinez? I feel he has never been top-5 MVP, so likely has 300+ HRs.  It I’m out of guesses for that range.

Harper and Manny both too good.

Goldy 3x

Harper 2x

Arenado 3x

Cutch 4x !

Machado 2x

Rizzo 2x

Santana 0x

Martinez 1x

Freeman 3x

Donaldson 2x

Not in range:

Pujols 10x

Trout 9x