HitsRus;1516750 wrote:t is doubtful that the Tribe could afford to keep both. I think it's critical to retain at least one of those guys plus Kazmir.
I totally agree they can't afford both.
Over a 4-5 year contract I would trust Masterson far more than Ubaldo to give the team their money's worth.
The flip side to that is I think that Masterson could potentially be more expensive, but they need to have talks with him before they talk to Ubaldo about an extension so they know their options.
If Masterson tells them he is looking for a huge payday, then you push harder to keep Ubaldo if his price is more reasonable.
It's a tough situation, but they absolutely have to find a way to keep at least one of those 2 as well as Kazmir if he can be had for the numbers you referenced.
If the Dolan's are smart, they might push themselves a bit on payroll this off-season with a free agent or 2 to try and generate some buzz and keep momentum going.
For the first time in a while they aren't coming off a terrible season, and if you add a few pieces to a 92 win team you might finally start turning around the poor ticket numbers as people would have legit reason to feel optimism the Tribe could be a contender. That should help start moving the needle a bit on ticket sales.