Steel Valley Football;433692 wrote:Herron broke all of Clarett's records at Warren Harding, though. Then, he broke Clarett's record for games played at OSU and semesters on the B10 All-Academic team.

thedynasty1998;433695 wrote:Yea, so?

Steel Valley Football;433702 wrote:Yea, so breaking tackles doesn't mean shit without some common sense to go with it. You fucking retarded or something?

thedynasty1998;433706 wrote:It meant a National Championship trophy for OSU fans.

thedynasty1998;433425 wrote:He clearly missed my point then. People claim OSU's backfield is stacked, and I said it wasn't, proof being that OSU doesn't have a #1 guy.

Arkansas and Auburn, which were used as examples, had two #1 guys.

I also never made the claim that OSU can't win without a #1 guy. I think they are just fine, especially when you factor in Pryor running the ball. OSU will be a top team this year, but would be even better with a true #1.

elbuckeye28;433792 wrote:I think most reasonable Ohio State fans realize that we do have a #1 guy, and that guy is Brandon Saine. He has really come back around after struggling a couple seasons ago.

Steel Valley Football;433713 wrote:WTF what huh? What is that doing for Clarett now?

thedynasty1998;433065 wrote:Loaded with average backs. The fact that OSU doesn't have a #1 tells me they don't have a stud.

This is probably for a different discussion, but on the Common Man & The Torg they were asking listeners, over the last 15 years if you could pick one guy to play on this years team, who would it be?

The first player that came to my mind was Clarett. The dude was a beast.

Trueblue23;433244 wrote:I would take Clarett over Wells anyday. Wells had a ton of talent, but he was a pussy. Clarett was the OSU version of Mike Hart.. a small, HARD running back who never gave up on a play.

thedynasty1998;434004 wrote:I do think he is the one that steps up and becomes the #1.

jmog;434043 wrote:Sorry man, but anyone who would take Clarett over Beanie Wells doesn't watch much football. Clarett was a beast, but Wells was bigger, more physical, and faster.

Pick6;434078 wrote:I thought it has already been said Saine is the #1 since Spring?

thedynasty1998;434006 wrote:He is attending school at Ohio State. Not really sure what you are trying to prove?

Little Danny;433357 wrote:Obviously Clarett is not going to be playing football for OSU. However, what strikes me is that he is able to get into OSU in the first place. I have had several family members and friends who were not able to get into OSU right away, they had to to go to a branch college first or Columbus State. These were good kids who actually were very good students in high school and had a decent ACT score. It's a shame a thug like Maurice seems to get in and they could not.

thedynasty1998;434079 wrote:Clarett had quicker feet, maybe better vision and was faster
Clarett stats his freshman year:
222 carries, 1237 yards, 5.6 avg

Wells stats:
Freshman - 104 carries, 576 yards, 5.5 avg (backup to Pittman)
Sophomore - 274 carries, 1609 yards, 5.9 avg (starter)
Junior - 207 carries, 1197 yards, 5.8 avg (injured)


One could obviously argue that Wells was better, however I would disagree. Clarett was dominant as a freshman, and if he didn't screw up, there was no reason to think he wouldn't have improved for his sophomore year.

jmog;434293 wrote:Clarett was faster? You lost all credibility with that post.

Steel Valley Football;434105 wrote:I made my initial point and you said "yea so". That makes you either a moron or just looking to start trouble. I sincerely hope it's the latter.

So, with this latest post, are you now trying to claim that, since Clarett is out of prison and re-enrolled at OSU, he is not one of the biggest mental failures to ever wear a buckeye uniform?

karen lotz;434390 wrote:I assume he is talking about his speed coming out of HS or at OSU, not the 4.8 or whatever he ran at the combine. Both Clarett and Wells have 40 times of 4.5 on scout/rivals coming out of high school.

Ironman92;433679 wrote:Clarett's best play at OSU was when he turned into a defender for a few moments versus Miami.

Tiernan;434416 wrote:No he's trying to say "give the man a break...he paid his debt" and now people like yourself are castrating the guy because he's trying to better himself. Bet you never made mistakes in your life did you SVF? (other than obviously choosing to reside in Youngstown aka Ohio's anus)