I’m going to guess Frank Robinson for the hitter. 

posted by BRF

I’m going to guess Frank Robinson for the hitter. 

I like the guess but who around 72 would’ve been the 300 win pitcher? Frank is incorrect

My next guess for the batter is Reggie Jackson. 
 

pitcher- Catfish Hunter maybe

edit: no, I think Catfish is not right

another stab - Steve Carlton

How about Phil Niekro?

posted by BRF

My next guess for the batter is Reggie Jackson. 
 

pitcher- Catfish Hunter maybe

 

edit: no, I think Catfish is not right

 

another stab - Steve Carlton

 

How about Phil Niekro?

Reggie is right...now close in time frame better on pitcher. Carlton and Niekro in that time

Is Gaylord Perry the pitcher?

posted by cat_lover

Is Gaylord Perry the pitcher?

 

No...3 left in that era

Seaver?

posted by justincredible

Seaver?

Yes...Reggie at age 40 and 540 HR hit 2 HR off of Seaver in 1986 as Seaver had around 308 career wins .....2 months late Reggie went deep 3 times and 7 RBI off of David Cone, Dennis Leonard and Quisenberry

Question #123

14 teams (not necessarily cities) have had an active player on their roster that had 600+ career HR

I’ll give you the obvious 1. Yankees 2. Giants 3. Braves

Nsme the other 11

Red Sox gotta be one of those (Ruth)

Duh....Indians, Twins, White Sox, Phillies, Orioles.....Thome

A-Rod -Rangers

posted by BRF

Red Sox gotta be one of those (Ruth)

 

No Red Sox player has ever played for them while have 600+ career HR

Babe ended with the Boston Braves of the NL

Reds

posted by BRF

Red Sox gotta be one of those (Ruth)

Duh....Indians, Twins, White Sox, Phillies, Orioles.....Thome

A-Rod -Rangers

 

Those 5 are all correct but Arod didn’t get the Rangers on this list

posted by justincredible

Reds

Yep

Seattle

posted by BRF

Red Sox gotta be one of those (Ruth)

Duh....Indians, Twins, White Sox, Phillies, Orioles.....Thome

A-Rod -Rangers

 

White Sox are correct but Thome didn’t get them there

posted by cat_lover

Seattle

Yep

3 teams left

Mets

posted by justincredible

Mets

Yep

Two teams left 

White Sox was Griffey?

posted by justincredible

White Sox was Griffey?

Yes

He was Seattle as well, right? 

Dodgers with Thome

posted by justincredible

He was Seattle as well, right? 

Yes and Reds