• Pujols 01-06 & 08-11
• Bonds 90-94 & 00-04
• Trout 12-present
• Ortiz 03-07
• Clark 87-89
• Belle 94-96
• Miggy 09-13
• Howard 06-09
• Giambi 00-02
• Arenado 16-18

Arenado!

posted by Al Bundy

Armas

Baylor

Evans

No x3

posted by Ironman92

Arenado!

Hey there! 

Keith Hernandez

posted by Al Bundy

Keith Hernandez

"I'm Keith Hernandez." But no. Had an 8th place between two top-5s.

• Pujols 01-06 & 08-11
• Bonds 90-94 & 00-04
• Trout 12-present
• Ortiz 03-07
• Clark 87-89
• Belle 94-96
• Miggy 09-13
• Howard 06-09
• Giambi 00-02
• Arenado 16-18

3 to go, guys!

I’m fucking tired

I'm forgetting who I guessed....lol

Want clues??

posted by Laley23

Want clues??

I'm fine with clues, but whatever Ironman wants

2 are active, 1 retired.

Bump

give you guys a bit, then drop a bigger clue.

Fucking Cutch

posted by Ironman92

Fucking Cutch

There you go!

I figured that one and 1 of the remaining 2 would take awhile. 

• Pujols 01-06 & 08-11
• Bonds 90-94 & 00-04
• Trout 12-present
• Ortiz 03-07
• Clark 87-89
• Belle 94-96
• Miggy 09-13
• Howard 06-09
• Giambi 00-02
• Arenado 16-18
• McCutchen 12-15
• Cano 12-14

Freddie Freeman?

posted by Al Bundy

Freddie Freeman?

Nope.

I’m out. Too many answers. I can’t remember who I’ve named in this one and they are all running together. I feel like the answer is something we’ve already said and that I would have to hunt you down and stab you

Braun

Posey

Both former Yankees. One active, one retired!

Cano

posted by Al Bundy

Cano

There is one. One to go!

Gooden

Strawberry

Mattingly

Paul o'neil