mhs95_06;1062282 wrote:They probably did a quick review, but I'm saying take time to thoroughly consider it. Doesn't the ref on the field make the final decision when he goes to review? Need to let him decide that important of a play.
I know you have to prove possession by maintaining possession thru a collision with the ground, if you have one, but coming in and stripping it doesn't prove you didn't have valid possession after you took three steps with the ball on which the play should be over once you have possession beyond the plane. Now if that play happened at the 20 yd line, I'll bet they would rule a fumble!
This is an example of why I don't like the field official looking at the review. Overturning a tough call lets everyone know you (or one of your crew) got it wrong. No one wants to admit they made a mistake. That's where I think college football has the best review policy. Impartial folks upstairs make the call.
Still, I think the NFL shot themselves in the foot by not taking the time and doing a thorough review. If nothing else, it would have shown that they wanted to make sure to everyone that they got the call right. By not reviewing the play they left themselves wide open to criticism.