There is obviously a difference in panning out (which you originally said) and being a Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Peyton Manning. Every quarterback that I have listed has had a pretty good career. Debatable is Fitz, because he hasnt had a lot of time yet.shook_17;1072329 wrote:schaub had some part in this years title. they can thank peyton mannings neck for having that title. schaub and romo don't lead their teams to divison titles year in and year out, let alone playoff victories. i don't care what they do in regular season. regular season stats don't mean shit, make it to the playoffs, make some noise then come talk to me. romo will NEVER be elite due to that fact he makes the same mistake year in and year out. also look at his roster, talent across the board, hard for a qb to fail there. schaub doesn't have a playoff victory either. i want division titles, confrence championships and superbowls not good stats. you don't like what i write iliketurtles block the shit.
LOL at the attempts to save face on your Romo and Schaub comments.
If McCoy gets a pass, then why cant Fitz? This was only his first year of being named the starter at the beginning of the season, and still only played in 8 games.He doesnt have shit to work with as well.se-alum;1072335 wrote:The first one when he was basically shunned by the coaching staff until he was forced to be thrown into the fire. Even if you want to count that year, it's still only 2 years(with lockout between seasons) that he has had to work with NFL coaches. Not to mention the changing of the offensive scheme.
Eh, I mean.. Nanee, Shockey, and Olsen were all first year additions, but whatever you say. Stewart, Williams(only 6 GP), and Smith were hampered by injuries in Clausen's year. Lafell was a Rookie.BR1986FB;1072346 wrote:Yet his first year was the year that gave us "hope" that he'd amount to something. And then he regressed...
Don't see Andy Dalton & Cam Newton, TRUE rookies, making excuses. And don't give me the "supporting cast" argument because Jimmy Clausen had essentially the same weapons as Newton and he sucked.
McCoy floundered in year two when he HAD his chances. Sure, WR's dropped passes and the O-Line wasn't stout, early, but McCoy repeatedly missed open receivers, threw behind them, etc. The first part of that scouting report on McCoy posted by COA was bullshit. It gave you the impression that McCoy was strong at hitting receivers in stride allowing them to get YAC. Nothing could be further from the truth.
Dalton has a very talented group of young WRs around him, which the Browns do not.
