hoops23;1123612 wrote:You're bitching about it being too early to say he's been the 2nd best player out of the draft, but yet you're claiming he's not. You can't have it both ways.
Your reading comprehension is horrific.
Mulva;1123292 wrote:I'm still not a fan of the pick and disagree with the "2 best players" comment, even though it's way too early to judge something like that.
I don't get what's confusing about that comment. It's way too early to make a definitive statement like "it looks like we got the best 2 players in the draft" when there are plenty of examples of all-star players who took up to 3-5 years to really hit their stride, but in my opinion
when it's all said and done I don't think it will be correct and even
if you want to make that judgment now (which can't be fairly done, but again I'm not the one who brought it up to begin with) the current on-court results don't back the claim up.
Saying "it looks like we got the 2 best players in the draft" has absolutely nothing to do with potential. It's making a claim based on what has been shown.
And I'm not bitching about anything. I'm giving a completely reasonable opinion, but because it isn't sucking the Cleveland dick you can't comprehend it. Which really isn't surprising from the guy who went nuts defending fucking Luis Valbuena and James Davis when I said they weren't good players. You are the ultimate homer. Which is fine, but it doesn't mean I'm bitching about anything because I don't do it too.
grodt;1123588 wrote:Maybe not, but I'm guessing the Spurs and Pistons were sure glad they had them when they were winning championships. I don't think you can put too high a price on interior defense.
I'm sure they were too. But I wouldn't personally have drafted them #4 overall. And those were 1st team all NBA defenders.
If you make the comparison to solid defenders who aren't at the all-NBA level - guys like Serge Ibaka or Kendrick Perkins, would anybody really want to use a top 5 pick on them?
Bowen, Wallace, Raja Bell, etc. all went undrafted (Alonzo Gee on a lesser level). Not only not top 5 picks. Undrafted. It's much easier to find someone who struggles offensively but can lock you down on D than it is to find someone who can straight fill it up offensively. Those are the guys who have superstar potential, and those are the guys I spend a top 5 pick on. If none of them are there, I trade back or trade out. It's why I disagreed with the pick then, it's why I disagree now. I don't think Thompson is ever going to be an all-star, and so at #4 overall that isn't worth it to me.
It's a personal opinion. We can move on whenever you guys want.