Oh. I must have read the BCS standings incorrectly. Luckily I still like football enough that I think I can stomach watching a 1 vs. 3 match up.dlazz;1001943 wrote:the national championship game is OSU/LSU. What we got is a #1 vs #3.
That helps. Thanks.Manhattan Buckeye;1001944 wrote:I think Okie St. should have got the nod over Bama. If LSU and Bama are the 2 best teams then a playoff would evidence that. I'm not overly impressed with Bama's record this year, not to the point where I would definitively say they are better than Okie St. (or other teams, like Stanford).
I have no idea how anyone can definitively say Bama is the second best team.
Wisky and MSU deserved to play in that game, due to what they done on the field. 'Bama does not deserve to play in the NCG, because they did nothing to warrant it. Not sure how those are the same.WebFire;1001963 wrote:So? Your point would still apply to the B1G championship.
The computers don't have SEC bias. Computers have OSU #2. They should be playing.Mulva;1001964 wrote:Oh. I must have read the BCS standings incorrectly
That was one of the 4 reasons I listed in the thread.se-alum;1001919 wrote:So what if 'Bama wins, can you actually call them National Champions being that LSU has already beat them? If LSU wins, we still haven't learned anything because we knew LSU was better than 'Bama. It's a NCG that serves no purpose.
Because you asked if Bama would be champs if they won. It's exactly the same.se-alum;1001973 wrote:Wisky and MSU deserved to play in that game, due to what they done on the field. 'Bama does not deserve to play in the NCG, because they did nothing to warrant it. Not sure how those are the same.
Let's fill in the blanks.se-alum;1001973 wrote:Wisky and MSU deserved to play in that game, due to what they done on the field. 'Bama does not deserve to play in the NCG, because they did nothing to warrant it. Not sure how those are the same.
So what if MSU wins, can you actually call them B1G Champions being that Wiscy has already beat them? If Wiscy wins, we still haven't learned anything because we knew Wiscy was better than MSU. It's a BCG that serves no purpose.
MSU winning last night, and 'Bama beating LSU in the NCG would be nothing alike. MSU winning last night, would be more like LSU beating 'Bama a second time, since MSU had already beaten Wisky once this year. Clearly you're mistaken about what happened in the first MSU/Wisky game.WebFire;1001990 wrote:Because you asked if Bama would be champs if they won. It's exactly the same.
PWN'D!!!!!se-alum;1002004 wrote:MSU winning last night, and 'Bama beating LSU in the NCG would be nothing alike. MSU winning last night, would be more like LSU beating 'Bama a second time, since MSU had already beaten Wisky once this year. Clearly you're mistaken about what happened in the first MSU/Wisky game.
Yes, I'm sorry. I had them mixed around for some reason.se-alum;1002004 wrote:MSU winning last night, and 'Bama beating LSU in the NCG would be nothing alike. MSU winning last night, would be more like LSU beating 'Bama a second time, since MSU had already beaten Wisky once this year. Clearly you're mistaken about what happened in the first MSU/Wisky game.
Yeah, I'm human. :rolleyes:Iliketurtles;1002018 wrote:PWN'D!!!!!
Not much PWN when my point is still valid.Iliketurtles;1002018 wrote:PWN'D!!!!!
Zombaypirate;1001940 wrote:I think both. On top of that that we have been lied too. We have told over and over ad nauseum, that the regular season is a playoff. In playoffs teams go home after they lose.
Wisky is the B1G champ only because those are the two teams that HAD to play in the game, and the winner would be considered the B1G champs, technically. Does it prove Wisky is better than MSU, not at all. If 'Bama wins, no questions are answered. It's unfair to LSU and it's unfair to the fans.WebFire;1002019 wrote:Yes, I'm sorry. I had them mixed around for some reason.
Question still stands, just switch it around.
Fly4Fun;1001985 wrote:That was one of the 4 reasons I listed in the thread.
Whether they have to play or are chosen, there is no difference.se-alum;1002038 wrote:Wisky is the B1G champ only because those are the two teams that HAD to play in the game, and the winner would be considered the B1G champs, technically. Does it prove Wisky is better than MSU, not at all. If 'Bama wins, no questions are answered. It's unfair to LSU and it's unfair to the fans.
At least OSU Michigan rematch would have a touchdown.cats gone wild;1001871 wrote:Read the last line in my post. You guys wouldnt of whined about that rematch. So, whats the difference this year, except that they are actually putting the 2 best teams in.
I suppose I'm an idiot, then.dlazz;1001980 wrote:If you think otherwise then you're either an SEC homer, or an idiot.
We'll just have to agree to disagree on that.WebFire;1002046 wrote:Whether they have to play or are chosen, there is no difference.
Was it their awesome win over Georgia Southern in their late season "bye" that convinced you?Mulva;1002057 wrote:I suppose I'm an idiot, then.
I think Alabama is the best team in the country. Not just #2.
Exactly. The SEC is the only conference who plays their cupcakes at the end of the season.Manhattan Buckeye;1002071 wrote:Was it their awesome win over Georgia Southern in their late season "bye" that convinced you?
Seriously, unless you play an independent (Notre Dame, Navy, etc.), it should be an NCAA rule that once the conference season starts, you play all in-conference games. The SEC is notorious for padding their schedules with this crap.
Manhattan Buckeye;1002071 wrote:Was it their awesome win over Georgia Southern in their late season "bye" that convinced you?
Seriously, unless you play an independent (Notre Dame, Navy, etc.), it should be an NCAA rule that once the conference season starts, you play all in-conference games. The SEC is notorious for padding their schedules with this crap.
They do, but at least they play their games in October, OSU's worst cupcake scheduling was New Mexico St. back in '09.karen lotz;1002086 wrote:South Carolina and Florida really padded their schedules like that. Ohio State and other big ten teams have played ooc games after big ten games have started in the past I believe.