rydawg5;1026464 wrote:Your opinion. Others have the same opinion about Tebow. Fact is, Peytton still was completing a little more than half his throws.
Honestly, other than winning (Im aware the statement in itself is a bit contradictory, cause winning is the end goal) what does Tebow do that makes him look like a good QB? I dont see how an argument can be made for him actually looking like a solid NFL QB. He looks really bad out there, and then wills wins out. We are starting to see that isnt gonna happen every week, and eventually not at all unless he can change his skill set and form. Problem is, unlike Manning, you dont see where improvements are gonna come from. Too tough to change a guys motion at this point in there life. His way of playing seems to be geared to one thing and adjustments will be very tough to come by. With Manning being the prototypical QB, he just had to learn the position. His mistakes were for the most part the cliche or "rookie mistake". With Tebow, those "rookie mistakes" look like poor form and lacking ability.
rydawg5;1026464 wrote:
No trying to compare them to say they are similar. But again, this is an opinion. The facts are, his statistics aren't showing any truth to your opinions that say that he can't play in this league due to his bad numbers. Because his bad numbers are about the same as HOFs in their first years.
No, the facts are showing exactly that. His form is showing that and his style is showing that. His work ethic and drive are showing he CAN play.
In Peytons case, the facts (stats) said he couldnt play. But his style, form, work ethic and drive all said he could. He had a lot more going for him that Tebow. I watched every game of Peytons career and 7/9 for Tebow this year. Stats and drive are all they have going for them similarly. But watching Peyton you knew with time he would perfect it. With Tebow, nothing but drive says he will be successful. He doesnt look good doing anything else.
Again, I hope the guy is successful. He seems very genuine and overall like a fantastic human being. The NFL and pro sports...heck the World itself could use a LOT MORE Tim Tebows. But Ive seen a lot of him, and I just dont see where he becomes anything but 5-6 win QB year in year out.
