I think we can rule out Florida-Alabama rematch.

Who plays Alabama?

While I think TCU has played extremely well this year, I think Cincinnati, being from a BCS conference, should get the bid.

Obviously this game is far from over (and I know a few things about talking before stuff is over :rolleyes: ), but what do you guys think:

TCU or Cinci?

TCU.

TCU, and hopefully this will get us closer to a PLAYOFF.

Ohio State!!!!!!

lol Can't knock me for trying.

It would be Cincinnati. Enough voters will bump an undefeated champion from a BCS conference over TCU, and Cincinnati will probably gain some extra ground in the computers beating a 9-2 Pitt. I'm thinking the top 5 would be:

1. Alabama
2. Cincinnati
3. Florida
4. TCU
5. Texas

Boise St, while playing the weaker schedule......had the best win of the bunch beating #7 Oregon

TCU.

My personal opinion: TCU
What would actually happen: Cincinnati

To bad TCU couldnt be in the Big12.

While I think Texas will get it going like they seem to do in the 2nd half of every game they play, this is a major problem in college football. All three teams in TCU, BSU and Cincy all have a legitamite argument on why they should be the team to play in the title, how do you tell one they are worthy but the other two are not.

Cleveland Buck wrote: It would be Cincinnati. Enough voters will bump an undefeated champion from a BCS conference over TCU, and Cincinnati will probably gain some extra ground in the computers beating a 9-2 Pitt. I'm thinking the top 5 would be:

1. Alabama
2. Cincinnati
3. Florida
4. TCU
5. Texas

I used to think the same thing. I'm leaning toward TCU maintaining enough votes to stay ahead of Cincy now. I really don't think the BCS folks would mind TCU being there because it offers some proof that the system is sound and rewards the right teams - they can use the fact that a non-AQ actually made the title game over a big six team as support that there is nothing unfair about the process. Cincy is expendable in that case, despite their conference affiliation, because they aren't a cash cow anyway.

Tigerfan00 wrote: To bad TCU couldnt be in the Big12.

While I think Texas will get it going like they seem to do in the 2nd half of every game they play, this is a major problem in college football. All three teams in TCU, BSU and Cincy all have a legitamite argument on why they should be the team to play in the title, how do you tell one they are worthy but the other two are not.

Boise doesn't belong in the conversation at all. Cincy has the conference affiliation and TCU has multiple impressive wins. Boise has neither and is easy to exclude.

I think Boise is the weakest of those 3 teams but they did beat Oregon

My guess is TCU

ccrunner609 wrote: A playoff would be awesome.

+1.