How many do we have so far?
Ruth, Williams, Foxx, Murray, A-Rod
Is Winfield a no?
posted by O-TrapWinfield
I took a stab with Cobb. I knew it was a longshot.
Winfield 5 passed Murray in 91, held it 92-94 and Murray passed him back in 1995
6 so far
Sweet.
Ruth, Williams, Foxx, Murray, Winfield, A-Rod
Hmm ...
Gehrig? Mays? Reggie?
DiMaggio? McCovey? Stargell?
posted by O-TrapSweet.
Ruth, Williams, Foxx, Murray, Winfield, A-Rod
Hmm ...
Gehrig? Mays? Reggie?
Gehrig only 4
Reggie 5 and Mays parts of 8 seasons
2 more....DUH
Hank Greenberg? Would’ve started right after Ruth, but I’m probably forgetting some people who had more.
Oh duh.
Aaron.
Did Griffey play long enough after Bonds? Was he ahead of him during any years prior? I feel he was
posted by O-TrapDiMaggio? McCovey? Stargell?
4, 4, 2
posted by O-TrapOh duh.
Aaron.
5...passed Mays in 1972
posted by Laley23Hank Greenberg? Would’ve started right after Ruth, but I’m probably forgetting some people who had more.
Good name....nope
Aaron and Bonds.
Missing 1 lol
Barry Bighead Bonds
Aaron?
posted by O-TrapAaron and Bonds.
Bonds 6
posted by Laley23Did Griffey play long enough after Bonds? Was he ahead of him during any years prior? I feel he was
2008-2010
posted by Laley23Hank Greenberg? Would’ve started right after Ruth, but I’m probably forgetting some people who had more.
Jimmie Foxx and Mel Ott tag teamed him
posted by Ironman922008-2010
Damn, and Bonds was ahead that whole time? Felt like Bonds took off while Griffey got injured. Thought maybe he had been the leader for a year or 2 before that happened. Like, around 2000.
posted by Laley23Damn, and Bonds was ahead that whole time? Felt like Bonds took off while Griffey got injured. Thought maybe he had been the leader for a year or 2 before that happened. Like, around 2000.
Some cat named Big Mac
Of course, at that point, the other roiders were probably ahead.
Question #108....which player (he’s a HOFer) was an active career HR leader but for the shortest time period?
Mickey
