I'm just getting back from the game... I haven't read the entire thread but I did go back a few pages...forgive me if I repeat.
While I do agree...no way McCoy loses that game today. You literally could not have played any worse than Weeden today, and they should have won.
McCoy isn't good, but he's not garbage
I agree. You win that game with McCoy. You can say whatever you want about his arm strength, but McCoy spent most of the time being hit, knocked down and pressured. He had no running game and he had no recievers worth a damn.
Today I saw a QB miss wide open receivers several times...not even SEE wide open recievers because he was locked on his primary receiver...and throw into coverage when their were better targets open. More than that, it seemed to me he had a fair amount of time to throw. While the O- line was terrible in opening holes for running backs, they did a fair job keeping Weeden upright. Despite that, he failed to make plays and made bad decisions.
Some body else on here said, and I concur...that may have been the worst performance by a NFL QB that I have ever seen. QB rating of 5.1...5.1 for christsake!... a 51 would have been bad enough!
I'd be curious on how that stacks up all time...worse QB rating of a guy who played the whole game. I might try to google that.