sportswizuhrd;1069152 wrote:says this guy about Loving...
I agree about Loving and Nigel. Not sure why so many of the recruiting services have Loving ahead of Nigel but Nigel brings more to the game than Loving, IMO. I would take Hayes ahead of Loving. I really like Donnal's game.
As far as your other players, is Cookie Monster(wtf?) ahead of Vito Brown(I don't know his class, I believe UM is looking at him too) or Getty's? I think so but haven't seen much of Brown and when I did he seemed disinterested. Also, Getty's is just big(reminds me of Storm Stanley).
Lol, I meant to say playing 4th best but I still have him 3rd. Brown is a junior I believe and very good. But he fouls a lot. Donnas went off for like 40 vs him 1 on 1. Gettys sucks, IMO. I'd have brown 5th in nwo
namod65;1069173 wrote:Because the program was in the dumps before he was hired, and he instantly turned it into an elite program. He has proven to be one of the best recruiters out there. He knows what he is doing. I'm not going to question him because I remember how it was before he was the coach.
I still remember a thread on the old site where everyone was talking about the state championship game Northland vs. Princeton. It was almost entirely guys who had not watched any HS basketball all year, but went to the championship game and thought it made them experts on who were the best prospects. This was before Weatherspoon was offered by Matta. Sully was basically double and triple teamed the whole game and JD went off for like 30 or something with a bunch of highlight dunks. EVERYONE, almost every poster in the thread was bashing and questioning Matta. They were so sure that he made the wrong choice and should have offered JD INSTEAD of Sully. I laughed at them back then and I'm still laughing about it now.
Fair enough. I was more asking why that's the default answer, not that you have to disagree with Matta, it's his boring to debate stuff when hats the counter argument. I like pols opinions on here, even when I disagree so is like to hear YoUR thoughts, not that you trust ur coach. Hope that makes sense.
GFU

. But forreal, commenting on an OSU recruit when an OSU fan asked about him should be ok on an OSu college thread.
Big Gain;1069474 wrote:VERY simple answer to a VERY simple question. Matta has FOUR Big Ten Championships in his 8 years at Ohio State. NO OTHER Big Ten coach has more than 2 since Matta has been in the Big Ten. Very difficult to put down the coach that is twice as successful as all of the other Big Ten head coaches.
See my answer from above. That is so boring and a cop out. Not that it's 100% wrong. But how about you enter the debate and admit you haven't seen enough of someone (or whatever the topic is, you don't know enough to make a judgment) and say so because of that I'll trust Thad.
If you can make your own judgement on said player or situation or whatever do so. If its the same as Matta at least you brought your own thoughts to he table and didn't resort to the "I'll trust the coach who has 57777 big ten titles over a random guy on the Internet" commets