Old Rider;1316102 wrote:I was curious to see how all the teams from Wayne County have benefitted (or not benefitted) from the OHSAA expanding to 8 teams per region back in 1999. So for whats its worth, here you go..
Prior to 1999 the WCAL teams had qualified for the playoffs a total of 12 times. Rittman(86), Smithville(84, 90, 94), Dalton(91, 92, 96), Waynedale(85, 92, 95, 97, 98).
Since 1999 the WCAL teams have qualified for the playoffs a total of 32 times. Rittman(05), Smithville(99, 00, 01, 02, 03, 04, 05, 06, 11), Dalton(01, 02, 03, 04, 05, 09, 10), Waynedale(03, 07, 08, 09),
Chippewa(99), Norwayne(08, 10, 11, 12), Northwestern(05, 06, 07, 12), Hillsdale(09, 10, 12).
And if anyone gives a hoot...Orrville made it 14 times prior to 1999 and has made it 8 times since. I could care less about wooster!
Part of this comes with being in a conference that is
traditionally so competitive that its champ(s) often come out with at least one league loss. In an 8-team league, your schedule only has three games of wiggle room to look for strong opponents whose records won't be watered down with inter-league play by default.
How many times, for example, have we seen a WCAL team in a lower seed beat a team in an upper seed? Now, obviously, the more teams you let in, the lower the competition gets in round 1, and the fewer times you'll see that happening, but with only 4 making it in a region, it was very, very possible to go 10-0 and miss the playoffs. Since opening it up, however, only one team has gone 10-0 and missed. It also did allow the first 3-win team to make the playoffs, which allows for an unusually brutal schedule to still not ruin one's chances (that team, Walsh Jesuit of D2R5, was 7th in the region at 3-6, and actually lost by less than a TD to the #2 seed in round 1 of the playoffs).
Red Rum;1316111 wrote:Old Rider,
Wouldn't we need to know how many of the 32 appearences since 1999 were seeds 5 through 8 to get an accurate picture. Same with Orrvilles 8 appearences since the expansion.
This is a fair question as well. I decided to check what I could.
Smithville finished 5th in 1999 and beat #4 Delphos Jefferson before losing to #8 Sycamore Mohawk. (1 playoff win as a 5-8 seed team)
Smithville finished 5th in 2000 and beat #4 Hemlock Miller and #1 Ashland Crestview before losing to #3 Amanda-Clearcreek. (2 playoff wins as a 5-8 seed team)
Smithville finished 8th in 2001 and beat #1 Amanda-Clearcreek and #4 Sarahsville Shenandoah before losing to #2 Woodsfield Monroe Central (2 playoff wins as a 5-8 seed team)
Smithville finished 7th in 2003 and lost in the first round to #2 Warren JFK. (0 wins as a 5-8 seed team)
Smithville finished 5th in 2004 and beat #4 Columbiana Crestview, #1 Gates Mills Gilmour Academy, and #6 North Lima South Range to be regional champs before losing to Region 19 champ Amanda-Clearcreek. (3 wins as a 5-8 seed team)
Smithville finished 8th in 2011 and lost in the first round to #1 Bucyrus Wynford. (0 wins as a 5-8 seed team)
So, overall, Smithville has a playoff record of 8-6 as a fifth to eighth seeded team. Winning record and one regional championship that wouldn't have happened under the old format. More 2+ win playoff appearances as a 5-8 seed than 0 win appearances.
I didn't include years when they finished #1-#4.