ernest_t_bass;907230 wrote:Meyer has never won big with his own recruited players, has he?
At a
minimum, 16 starters on the 2008 championship team were Meyer recruits. That's just off the top of my head.
karen lotz;907337 wrote:And I think he was only at BG for 2 years so its kind of hard to say he won with his own players.
Perhaps they weren't his own players, but BG had six straight losing seasons prior to Meyer's arrival, including 2-9 right before he was hired. Utah was coming off a losing record when he took over there. Florida had three straight, 5-loss seasons.
In every case, Meyer might not have won "with his own players," but he certainly took the program to a completely different level within 1-2 years.
bigkahuna;907330 wrote:He could have the Rich Rod affect (Pat White), where people show his W/L record with Tebow/Smith and without Tebow/Smith
With Tebow/Alex Smith 70-9 (6 years) Without Tebow/Alex Smith 30-14 (4 years)
Your numbers are a little off. Tebow started 3 years with a record of 35-6 (yes, he was a contributor his freshman year). Alex Smith was 22-2 with Meyer. That is 57-8. When one of those guys wasn't the starter, he was 47-15. Winning 75% of your games isn't a bad clip and it is a lot different than Rich Rod, who was right around .500 (FBS) without Pat White.
Obviously good coaches are going to do better when they have great players. But there are plenty of great quarterbacks with good coaches who don't: a) go undefeated or b) win a National Championship.
Meyer has his flaws as a coach, but to act as though his record was handed to him by someone else (you still have to plug them in) or based on having one star player is silly.