Hb31187;688532 wrote:Kobe
Rose
Wade
Lebron
Howard
Durant
Not in order at all, but off the top of my head those are the only players above Melo, im sure i missed 1 maybe 2 players, but id love to see 14 players listed better than Melo

thedynasty1998;688678 wrote:The guy who insults everyone else's NBA knowledge comes up with that list for top 15 guys in the NBA?

Putting Horford and Aldridge in the same list as Carmelo is laughable.

thedynasty1998;688678 wrote:The guy who insults everyone else's NBA knowledge comes up with that list for top 15 guys in the NBA?

Putting Horford and Aldridge in the same list as Carmelo is laughable.

mallymal614;688738 wrote:And the West is getting easier and easier for the Lakers. All of the star power in that conference is shifting to the East. L.A. don't have to go through the likes of a Boston, Miami, Knicks, and/or Bulls to make the finals. If they can just get pass San Antonio, they are fine.

Skyhook79;688702 wrote:I would put Gasol and CP3 above Melo also, not because they are better basketball players necessarily but I would pick them before Melo on my team. Melo is top 10 for sure.

september63;688768 wrote:Carmelo Anthony has made the All NBA 3rd team three times and 2nd team once. That alone suggests he falls between 10-15.

Midstate01;688781 wrote:has lemarcus aldridge been all nba?
Blake Griffin been all nba?
You keep trying too hard to prove your point

Skyhook79;688786 wrote:Not that I agree with your premise but using the same fact you used, I could say he ranks somewhere between 6-11.

september63;688806 wrote:Everyone has opinions. CBS Sports writers get paid to cover the league too. They have Carmelo #18 and Williams # 12.

september63;688806 wrote:Everyone has opinions. CBS Sports writers get paid to cover the league too. They have Carmelo #18 and Williams # 12.

lhslep134;688800 wrote:Ya'll are nuts. Melo is arguably (by REAL NBA experts who are paid to study the NBA) the most versatile scorer (read it on twitter, forget who, either Hollinger or Bucher) in the league. He might not play defense and that's why he's 2nd or 3rd team NBA, but in terms of offensive ability he's first team all NBA without a doubt.

HB, you've watched Melo for 7.5 years in Denver, I think you'd agree.

Hb31187;688824 wrote:Yes I would Agree, he has everything but a 3 point shot in his offensive arsenal. He literally has every other type of offensive move you can think of. Post up, Midrange, finish above the rim, finish with contact, cross over, quick first step, size ect ect

Commander of Awesome;688494 wrote:IMO Deron Williams is a much better basketball player than Carmelo Anthony. A great PG is more valuable than a stat sheet volume scorer who in completely uninterested in playing defense. Williams is a top 5 player in the league, while Melo is a ~ top 15-20 player.

lhslep134;688800 wrote:He might not play defense.

Commander of Awesome;688543 wrote:LBJ
Durrant
CP3
Williams
Kobe
Pau Gasol
Dwade
Derrick Rose
Blake Griffin
Howard
Dirk
Al Hortford
LaMarcus Aldridge
Paul Pierce
Tim Duncan
Amare'
then I'd list Melo.

Not exactly in that order but I'd put Melo at the bottom of that list.

Jester;688934 wrote:IPOTW.

Jester;688934 wrote:IPOTW.