Swamp Fox;395033 wrote: I thought Wedge did a nice job in Cleveland and while he did sometimes get off to a slow start and things didn't go swimmingly well, the team generally performed at a decent level and could at least compete at an acceptable, if not "World Series" like consistency.
You HAVE to be kidding?
68-94
80-82
93-69
78-84
96-66
81-81
65-97
Wedge's teams were the definition of inconsistent. The only things you could count on under his teams was that they would start slow and fall apart when it really mattered. He was an awful, awful manager.
I said at the time that Acta was hired that he was the worst possible person they could have brought in, because he's just not a good manager. BUT... I also said that nobody in the world could win with this team, and that I wouldn't get on the fire Acta bandwagon until they legitimately had enough talent to win (I did the same with Wedge... wasn't calling for his head until after the total meltdown in 2005).
The real blame for this team falls on 1 person and 1 person alone (and no it isn't Dolan): it's Mark Shapiro. You can say "Dolan won't spend" all you want, but the truth is that Shapiro is just a complete fucking dumbass when it comes to everything a GM should be able to do. He drafts horribly, gets fleeced right and left on trades (those Sabathia and Lee deals are looking great Mark!), and couldn't pick out a decent free agent to save his life. When he was given the money to spend he just put it all in the wrong places. Example...
Jake Westbrook, Travis Hafner, and Kerry Wood make up over 1/2 of the Indians payroll. When 3 average to below average players are being given $30+ million in a small to mid-market team it is no surprise that the owner is dumping salary and the team is losing games. Those are just 3 horrific contracts. And none of that is retrospect, because there were plenty of people at the time the deals were made asking why a guy who was a career DH was being given that much, or why a closer was a #1 priority over a starter. Shapiro is a fuckup, and the fact that he is being promoted tells just how terrible this organization is and explains why so many people (myself included, unfortunately) are now completely apathetic towards the team.