Been starting Matt Schaub most of the season, and he has been a disappointment. Started Eli last week, and he raked, and I am a Giants fan so I love having him in my lineup. I was going to start Manning (vs. Dallas) over Schaub (vs. Jax) this week, but with Steve Smith out (and Schaub facing a terrible defense), and I am torn.

What do you guys think?

Eli always torches the cowboys

Eli.

Damn, Schaub with 287 yards and 2 TDs on my bench so far ... Eli better step up later today!

Meanwhile, Adrian Peterson is absolutely killing me today. COME ON MAN!

Same question for this week (week 14): Schaub tonight at home vs. Baltimore, or Eli Manning at Minnesota (well, actually Detroit, vs. the Vikings)?

I am going with Schaub. Shouldn't make a difference, I am losing a close game, but I have FIVE guys tonight: Schaub/Eli, Peterson, Rice, Manningham and Rackers ...