sjmvsfscs08 wrote:
ghosthunter wrote:
sjmvsfscs08 wrote:
ghosthunter wrote:
I agree that all 18 year old and above that are currently on Active duty should be allowed to drink. For everyone else though; 21 works.
I would agree with that, but I'm inclined to believe that we are all created equal and that flies in the face of everything that stands for. I think the age should be nineteen.
Not necessarily. You see, if you get in trouble aboard a military base you are subject to the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) not the civilian statute for the crime, even if there is one. In a nutshell, the military could allow drinking on their bases at the age of 18 (Camp Pendelton, Ca. did this in the 80's) if they chose to do so. The Marines were about the only one's that allowed this however, and pressure form liberal groups finally forced them to revert to the civilian age of 21.
The last thing you'd want is for your military to be drinking anyway. People are a bit more mature by 21 to be able to handle it, plus a kid joining the military at 18 would be pestered by his friends to get him alcohol constantly and that would leas to a whole bunch of badness.
A flat requirement of 19 is suitable in my opinion; 92% of college kids drink anyway.
The penalties, however, for an alcohol related incident for a first term military member (an individual on their very first enlistment which the majority of are under age 21) are very strict. For example, you miss the morning formation @ 7:00 am because you were to drunk to get out of the rack, would in all likelihood send this individual to level 3 alcohol counseling (essentially AA) and there's a very good chance they would be denied reenlistment if they wanted to do another hitch. I knew many fine Marines this happened to. Obviously a drunk 19 year old who misses class for the same reason is not going to suffer any legal ramifications.
The point being is that there are many control measures in place within the structure of the military that do not exist within civilian society. It's these measures that lead me to believe if a kid can take a bullet for his country then he should be able to drink at 18 aboard a US military base.
It's been good conversing with you, but I think we've "hi-jacked" the thread.