vball10set;1803521 wrote:Well I'm glad to see you'll take it like a man-lol...my point is he's dispensable, especially if we pick up McCall or Lucroy

If it truly is a separated shoulder, by the time he recovers and does a minor league rehab stint, we will be expanding the rosters. I don't see any trade with him during the season happening.

Go get Chappy! Gotta go for it this year.

I'd prefer Miller for the control through 2018. But it all depends on what you have to give up for either.

Ironman92;1803525 wrote:Go get Chappy! Gotta go for it this year.

heck yes

Al Bundy;1803524 wrote:If it truly is a separated shoulder, by the time he recovers and does a minor league rehab stint, we will be expanding the rosters. I don't see any trade with him during the season happening.

good point

Ironman92;1803525 wrote:Go get Chappy! Gotta go for it this year.

iclfan2;1803531 wrote:I'd prefer Miller for the control through 2018. But it all depends on what you have to give up for either.

either or, but get one of them

Miller would be nice. But I'd much rather give up more for Chapman. I know it's the rental vs 2.5 years. But he is just a much better and bigger weapon in the postseason. Miller has been amazing, but I'd still rather Chapman in the postseason out there in the late innings versus a dangerous lefty (or righty).

BUMP THREAD

Chapman, Miller, Lucroy etc.

Laley23;1803535 wrote:Miller would be nice. But I'd much rather give up more for Chapman. I know it's the rental vs 2.5 years. But he is just a much better and bigger weapon in the postseason. Miller has been amazing, but I'd still rather Chapman in the postseason out there in the late innings versus a dangerous lefty (or righty).

LOLOLOL.

Of course Chapman was great for Cubs till Maddon misused him, but holy hell Andrew Miller.