thavoice;1680729 wrote:I would be very surprised if that was true, but lets assume it is.
Still nothing beats game time reps and he just doesnt have them.
The committee has to be losing sleep on this one and what they should do. Losing your QB that put up the numbers like Barrett did makes this a whole different team.
MY PERSONAL OPINION:
They don't need to be losing sleep or anything over Ohio State right now. They have a game remaining against a team that (in human polls) is immediately outside the Top 10. They were 6th in the playoff poll coming into last week's games and, so, due to MSU losing, they should be fifth.
On Saturday, at a neutral field, against a near-Top-10 team, we'll all know if the team can jump on the field with Cardale instead of JT and still look good. If they lose, they're out by a mile. If they win in a "normal" football game and teams above them lose, they're in. If they win a horribly ugly game where both teams look like utter shit regardless of what anyone else does OR if they win and the teams above and near them also win, things get interesting because in the former, the committee will see that it's not the same team with Cardale and in the latter, there's a huge-ass log-jam with them and the two Big 12 teams (#4 TCU plays a chump, while both OSU and Baylor have tough, ranked opponents).
If the Barrett injury happened in the B1G championship game, then yeah, I'd agree the committee has some tough thinking to do about things concerning Ohio State and their place in the rankings. But now...at the least, there's a full week of football with a lot of high-profile games to sort everything out. All the committee has to do is sit back, stay the current course and let Friday and Saturday sort out who the top four teams are.