Automatik;1756782 wrote:I don't care. I still want them in the Confed Cup. It sure as hell doesn't hurt to play those games.
It doesn't? How do Confederations Cup games help teams?
1997 -
Brazil (1), Australia (2), Czech Republic (3), Uruguay (4)
2001 - France (1), Japan (2), Australia (3),
Brazil (4)
2005 - Brazil (1), Argentina (2),
Germany (3), Mexico (4)
2009 - Brazil (1), US (2),
Spain (3), South Africa (4)
2013 -
Brazil (1), Spain (2), Italy (3), Uruguay (4)
World Cup
1998 - France (1),
Brazil (2), Croatia (3), Netherlands (4)
2002 -
Brazil (1), Germany (2), Turkey (3), South Korea (4)
2006 - Italy (1), France (2),
Germany (3), Portugal (4)
2010 -
Spain (1), Netherlands (2), Germany (3), Uruguay(4)
2014 - Germany (1), Argentina (2), Netherlands (3),
Brazil (4)
Of the past 5 Confederations Cups, one team that finished top 4 have finished top 4 in the following year's World Cup (Brazil happened to be 3 of those). No Confederations Cup winners have won the World Cup. No second place Confederations Cup finishers have won the World Cup. Only one time, 2009 Spain (third) to 2010 Spain (champs) actually show "improvement" by playing in the Confederations Cup, 2005 Germany and 2006 Germany both finished third. That means, three times a Confederations Cup winner has finished worse in the World Cup -- 2001 France, 2005 Brazil, and 2009 Brazil all won the Confederations Cup and didn't finish top 4 in the World Cup.
USMNT in the Confederations Cup to World Cup results:
1997: N/A 1998: 4th in Group F
2001: N/A 2002: 2nd in Group D, Knockout win, Quarterfinals loss
2005: N/A 2006: 4th in Group E
2009: 2nd 2010: 1st in Group C, Knockout loss
2013: N/A 2014: 2nd in Group G, Knockout loss
So, what can we draw from this all? Not much. It's not like the Confederations Cup "helps" anyone achieve a higher finish in the World Cup. Sure, competition is nice...but we can always get competition from teams depending on we schedule friendlies. I'm not concerned with missing the Confederations Cup, nor do I think it should hurt Klinsmann.