Not even close.

No to many other wrs were better during hi time. If Chris Carter isn't in Smith is no where close.

Derrick Mason - NO
Torry Holt - Maybe
Chad Johnson - Maybe
Marvin Harrison - Yes
Reggie Wayne - Yes
Jimmy Smith -Hell No
Anquan Boldin No
Larry Fitzgerald - Yes
Andre Johnson - Yes
Keyshawn Johnson - No
Donald Driver - No
Joey Galloway - Hell No
Terrell Owens - Yes
Randy Moss - Yes
Keenan McCardell - Hell No
Muhsin Muhammad - Hell No
Rod Smith - No
Hines Ward - Yes
Isaac Bruce -No
Santana Moss - No
Tim Brown - Yes
Wes Welker - No
, Calvin Johnson- Yes
, Brandon Marshall - No,
Marques Colston - No
, Greg Jennings - Maybe
, Dwayne Bowe - No
, Santonio Holmes No