sportchampps;1615664 wrote:I would say they are both in the top 10 easily.
Possibly, I would put them near the bottom of that top 10 or outside of it.
Just off the top of my head, Frank Mir, Big Nog, Jacare, Magahlaes, Roger Gracie, Shinya Aoki, Maia, Rousimar Palhares, Werdum, and BJ Penn all better guards. Some of them aren't top tier MMA fighters, but they are good MMA fighters with better guards than the Diaz brothers.
Now, every single one of them except Mir have some top tier BJJ/grappling championships from Abu Dhabi, etc. Mir's best grappling only credential is a NAGA championship but he has pulled armbars, triangles, kimuras, heel hooks and knee bars all out of his guard in the UFC, against top ground guys like Big Nog.
Are the Diaz brothers top 10 guard guys "easily" if we are only talking top tier MMA fighters (guys in the top 10 of their division)? Absolutely, because then guys like Roger Gracie, Shinya Aoki, Magalhaes, Palhares, etc drop out of the discussion, but that would be moving the goal posts.