BR1986FB;911547 wrote:Gotta vent...after listening to talk radio and looking at message boards I'm kinda pissed. I keep hearing the "Browns fans are the GREATEST fans on the planet." I'm starting to think they are the ****tiest.
ALL I've heard is "yeah, they won but it didn't FEEL like a win", "they won but it wasn't impressive enough" or bitching and moaning about Shurmur's play calling or Shurmur as a head coach, etc. THEY ARE 2-1 PEOPLE !!!! THE LAST TIME THEY STARTED THE SEASON 2-1 WAS 2002.
They have 10 rookies or second year players starting, the team just came off a lockout with minimal time to prepare and Shurmur has coached THREE games as a HC. Hell, listening to Chuck Booms on 92.3 this morning you'd have thought he was pining for Mangini's return (BTW...this team would be 0-3 under Mangini right now, book it). It's like they expect Shurmur to be the reincarnation of Bill Walsh/Chuck Noll/Don Shula ALL rolled up into one.
This team is young and the roster hasn't been completely filled out. There WILL be growing pains with this new offense, especially with the lack of potent receivers.
Enjoy the wins while they're getting them because there may not be a whole lot of them. It would be ONE thing to bitch & moan if they were losing and the the offense was this vanilla but they're NOT, they're WINNING.
End rant
This is my take, for what very little it's worth.
First of all, any fan that doesn't see the win as "good enough" probably isn't a true fan. After the pitiful performance on offense for 57 minutes, they were more than lucky to come out of that game with a win.
You're right, this team is very very young. 10 starters with, at most, 2 years starting in the league? That's mind boggling, but exactly what a franchise needs to be successful for the future (Green Bay anyone?). I've noticed that a lot of fans - on this forum, and radio shows - that aren't happy with Colt McCoy. While I'm not thrilled with McCoy's performance either, it's way - WAY - to early to say he's not the guy the Browns need at QB.
He probably faced one of this worst possible scenarios a rookie has ever faced coming into the league. Mangini did him absolutely ZERO favors with the way he handled him as a rookie. Then, throw in the fact that this off-season was one unlike any other, a new offense, new players, etc. - and you're damn right there's going to be some growing pains. If, after next season, these questions still surround McCoy, then fine - no, he's probably not our answer at QB. But when is the last time a Browns team has gone through the season without a QB controversy? Even after Anderson's Pro-Bowl year, everyone was calling for Quinn to take his job. (Fans seen how great that worked out). You'd think, that after years of failed success, that fans would be happy with a 2 game winning streak, and a 2-1 start to the year, but I truly believe that, no matter what, until this team wins a Super Bowl - fans are going to continue to be picky.
Regarding Hillis', everyone says that he looked like hell the day before the game, and said the same thing on gameday. Sure, you like to see him at least TRY to go, but strep throat sucks ass, so it's hard to fault the guy for skipping the game. And anyway, Shurmur hasn't come out and said that he sent Hillis home, or Hillis wanted to go home. What it did do, however, is show us what MoHard can really do if he has the opportunity. I think, if he can stay healthy, he'll eventually be the feature guy, but will have to spend most of his time splitting carries with Hillis. Why else would they be lobbying for an extension for Hillis? I think they should put Hillis contract talks on hold, at least for now, see how the two backs progress through the season, and analyze the situation after the season is over.