vball10set;1407204 wrote:Saw Life of Pi on VOD last night- how in the hell was it even mentioned in the same breath as Argo and Lincoln?
#1 (and most important)

opularity of book
#2 visual effects
#3 feel-good story that the Academy always likes (see Forrest Gump and Slumdog Millionaire)
I agree it wasn't on par with the two films you mentioned, but it was tailor made to get nominated (and in some cases win) awards. I thought it was ok but have no desire to watch it again. I saw the story and the effects and was glad I saw it but that was it. That said many of my friends absolutely loved it.