queencitybuckeye;850494 wrote:Interesting factoid included, but don't even dream that it means he's in the same galaxy as Calvin Johnson.

A top 10 Wr..pretty safely id say. A top 10 PLAYER? Thats very very very questionable, and if he is, hed be 9 or 10. And Calvin Johnson played on a team that had HORRRRRIBLE qbs and nobody to take the attention off of him.

Off the top of my head Wr's better than him in the past decade. Calvin Johnson, Larry Fitzgerald, Braylon Edwards, Michael Crabtree. Theres just 4 Wr's off the top of my head. Hes a hell of a player, but top 10 in the past decade is a really really realllllly special group of players.

slingshot4ever;850505 wrote:Plus the fact that Joe Thomas was and will always be better than Long....

Judging tackles is pretty much all opinion

Speedofsand;847333 wrote:1. Tim Tebow, QB, Florida
2. Glenn Dorsey, DT, LSU
3. Darren McFadden, RB, Arkansas
4. David Pollack, DE, Georgia
5. Patrick Willis, LB, Ole Miss
5. Eric Berry, S, Tennessee
5. Eli Manning, QB, Ole Miss
5. Percy Harvin, RB/WR, Florida
5. Mark Ingram, RB, Alabama
5. Rolando McClain, LB, Alabama

What a fucking TERRIBLE list. Way to pick all SEC homers dick licker.

Hb31187;851367 wrote:A top 10 Wr..pretty safely id say. A top 10 PLAYER? Thats very very very questionable, and if he is, hed be 9 or 10. And Calvin Johnson played on a team that had HORRRRRIBLE qbs and nobody to take the attention off of him.

Off the top of my head Wr's better than him in the past decade. Calvin Johnson, Larry Fitzgerald, Braylon Edwards, Michael Crabtree. Theres just 4 Wr's off the top of my head. Hes a hell of a player, but top 10 in the past decade is a really really realllllly special group of players.

To add to your list off the top of my head: Mike Williams (USC), Mario Manningham (Michigan), Santonio Holmes (OSU)