My fellow Americans,
First, to address my false allegations regarding Santorum and thongs, I offer my interest apologies for the auto-correct function of my keypad and even more for my lack of spell-checking.
Now then:
jhay78;1060217 wrote:I'm questioning your understanding of the bolded part.* I believe that quote came in the context of a Supreme Court decision (don't remember the name off the top of my head), which basically said states can't legislate against moral behavior as long as it doesn't harm anyone.* I know that sounds great to you libertarians, but what Santorum said was if that is indeed true, then states can't ban bestiality, adultery, and other less-than-acceptable forms of behavior.
*
Actually, I remember it, and I understood it just fine.* I actually agreed with him on some of the other comparisons (polygamy, in particular).* However, the nature of bestiality ... which involves sex between two or more parties, at least one of which cannot consent at the present moment ... would preclude it from being a "victimless crime."
*
I actually just looked up the quote and its surrounding text, and the statement was riddled with silly or false statements.* I'll cite:
*
"If the Supreme Court says you have a right to have consensual sex within your home, then [...] you have the right to adultery."* (Does he not know that we DO have a right to adultery?)
*
"Does that undermine the fabric of our society? I would argue yes, it does. It all comes from, I would argue, this right to privacy that doesn’t exist in my opinion in the United States Constitution."* (Has he read it?* Hardly a matter of "opinion.")
*
"In every society, the definition of marriage has not ever to my knowledge included homosexuality."* (I'm floored.* There is documented evidence to suggest a LOT of cultures through history have accepted same-sex partners, though admittedly, marriage hasn't always been such a state-strangled issue.)
*
With things like incest and polygamy, though, I agree with him.* I just think they should also be handled at a state level.
*
As an aside, he did also say that gay marriage was a "threat to the American family" (I think I got the quote correct, but this is off the top of my head, so correct me if I'm wrong).
*
Don't get me wrong.* I have absolutely ZERO problem with prohibiting it at the state and local levels.* As I recall, the current Presidential favorite of "us Libertarians" has voted to prevent same-sex marriages in his local elections.* I would vote differently, but I have no problem with him, or anyone else, doing so at the state or local level.* That's how it's supposed to work.
*
jhay78;1060217 wrote:What he said was absolutely true, but of course leftists and Ron Paul types took it to mean that Santorum thinks homosexuality = bestiality in nature.
*
Not at all.* Us "Ron Paul types" merely pointed out the error in him comparing them, only in the case of bestiality.* There was a baby in his bathwater, but the bathwater was disconcerting to say the least.
*
jhay78;1060217 wrote:The birth control thing was blown way out of proportion ...
*
The official quote:
*
"The state has a right to do that, I have never questioned that the state has a right to do that. It is not a constitutional right, the state has the right to pass whatever statutes they have. That is the thing I have said about the activism of the Supreme Court, they are creating right, and they should be left up to the people to decide."
*
I'll give you that one, though I find it curious that he's suddenly such a champion of the states' rights to deal with ethics after his position on same-sex marriage at the Federal level.* Seems awfully convenience-driven; would you not agree?
*
jhay78;1060217 wrote:... the women-staying-at-home thing is a non-issue, in fact might be supported by many family psychologists ...
*
I have never seen or heard of an article saying that a woman staying home was better for her.
*
jhay78;1060217 wrote:... and I thought the Palestinian thing was a Newt quote.* But other than that, you're right, he's nuts.
*
Nope.* It was Santorum.* Here's the quote:* "There are no Palestinians. All the people who live in the West Bank are Israelis. There are no Palestinians. This is Israeli land."
*
I actually appreciate Santorum.* All his ideas are not bad, and at least when he has a disconcerting thought, it comes out, and he doesn't hide anything.* Makes it easy to determine whether or not he's your guy.
*
As an Evangelical American, I'd probably agree with him on many things morally, but I vehemently disagree with his belief in a strong governmental authority over the moral lives of the citizens of the country.