karen lotz;717612 wrote:You still haven't figured this out?? Pearl's punishment was HALF OF HIS CONFERENCE SCHEDULE. It was also handed down by the SEC, not the NCAA which will surely add on. It is unlikely that Pearl will be employed by Tennessee next year considering the AD's recent comments. Tressel has now been suspended for one conference game, and his suspension is self imposed. You keep comparing the two as if Tressel's punishment is much worse than Pearl's. While it is a stronger penalty now than it was, the first 4 games don't mean anything towards a conference title. And I know your response will be "One preseason loss in football eliminates you from the National Championship." I will preemptively say that if OSU loses to a team like Toledo or Akron because Tressel is suspended, they aren't going to win the National Championship anyway.
You still haven't figured out that Ohio State could be better off with Tressel missing Big Ten games, having someone else call the offense's plays?
You still haven't figured out that the majority of the time the NCAA doesn't "surely add on" when the school/league is proactive and self imposes reasonable punishment?
You still haven't figured out that, the comparison of the 2 is done because the bylaw broken is the same and the occurrences were in the approximate same time period, thus the best comparison to make.
You still haven't figured out that the NCAA doesn't mete out punishment for the purpose of eliminating a team from winning a conference title or post season play?
You still haven't figured out that Tennessee wasn't going to win the SEC title even if Pearl coached every game? And they made the NCAA Tournament.
Please show us where I said Tressel's punishment is "much worse than Pearl's", all I've done is note the difference in the % of games.
You preemption was worthless. You actually thought Ohio State would go undefeated next year with the 5 game suspensions of the players? 5 game suspensions AND 5 games behind their opponents in game experience for the season. Thus it is immaterial which 5 games Tressel misses. If the NCAA's purpose was to eliminate Ohio State from winning a Big Ten Title and eliminate them from contention for a BCS Bowl game, then why didn't they punish the players by holding THEM out of 5 Big Ten games????????