Well shit George Strait doesn't have huge stage presence then. I have been to many of his concerts he gets on the stage and sings.

Tiger2003;706784 wrote:Well shit George Strait doesn't have huge stage presence then. I have been to many of his concerts he gets on the stage and sings.

So now we are comparing this punk to George Strait?

Tiger2003;706778 wrote:I would love to hear you sing The River if it is terribly easy. Scotty has been very consistent. He had one performance he didn't perform at his best but other then that he has been a top 4 singer every time.

It's easy to be consistent when you sing songs like "Letters from Home" & "The River" You can stay in your little comfort zone of notes.

Rydawg sorry you were abused when you were a little boy. This kid is talented and he will make it a far in this competition. He is a good singer and has a good voice. The stage presence will come once he gets with professionals remind you he is only 17 and still a high school student. Oh may I remind you that the judges applauded him for his answer last night " saying he will stay in his comfort zone" like Steven Tyler said " if it ain't broke don't fix it". But then again you know so much more about music then Steven Tyler.

Howd you know my life story? I can record a version and all I'm saying is, he better be 100x better than me to be on a stage with 11 people left in American Idol. I basically think everyone up there is 100x's better than me except for Scotty Don't

rydawg5;706817 wrote:Howd you know my life story? I can record a version and all I'm saying is, he better be 100x better than me to be on a stage with 11 people left in American Idol. I basically think everyone up there is 100x's better than me except for Scotty Don't

Oh shit dude can I get your autograph. Please.

Tiger2003;706820 wrote:Oh shit dude can I get your autograph. Please.

I don't do autographs. I'm just saying hes not much better than anything you'd see at a karaoke bar. He has a nice deep tone, but isn't a great singer.

rydawg5;706824 wrote:I don't do autographs. I'm just saying hes not much better than anything you'd see at a karaoke bar. He has a nice deep tone, but isn't a great singer.

Ok the 3 judges are complete fucking idiots and have no idea what the fuck they are doing.

Tiger2003;706828 wrote:Ok the 3 judges are complete fucking idiots and have no idea what the fuck they are doing.

I don't think so. This isn't only a singing contest (only the naive believe this) -- They compiled a group of diverse singers and ethnics that are naturally liked by many different regions and cultures to basically maximize the ratings.

I think he CAN be very good, but it's probably his youth that annoys me.

Also, when I mentioned "comfort" zone of songs, I didn't mean for him to rap a Lil Wayne song, but to simply stretch his vocal range.

rydawg5;706833 wrote:I don't think so. This isn't only a singing contest (only the naive believe this) -- They compiled a group of diverse singers and ethnics that are naturally liked by many different regions and cultures to basically maximize the ratings.

I think he CAN be very good, but it's probably his youth that annoys me.

Also, when I mentioned "comfort" zone of songs, I didn't mean for him to rap a Lil Wayne song, but to simply stretch his vocal range.

Well I am ok with him not stretching his vocals so far. He has done back to back solid Performances. I think in the weeks to come he will stretch his vocals a little more as long as he is still in the competition.

rydawg5;706833 wrote:I don't think so. This isn't only a singing contest (only the naive believe this) -- They compiled a group of diverse singers and ethnics that are naturally liked by many different regions and cultures to basically maximize the ratings.

I think he CAN be very good, but it's probably his youth that annoys me.

Also, when I mentioned "comfort" zone of songs, I didn't mean for him to rap a Lil Wayne song, but to simply stretch his vocal range.

You have a point here. But, I disagree with you and think Scotty is good and as others noted, will be a country and western singer sooner than later. Back to your point, Scotty will go far in this show because he does fit the C&W demographic. Folks in rural parts of this country will vote for him all day and all night, thus he will last a long while on this show.

I am a married man and answered in the negative formerly, but I am starting to rethink my "Hall Pass" thread if she were available.

Bottom three were Karen, Ashton, and Haley???(WTF)



....and Ashton goes home. Rightfully so.

Karen and Naima should be next on the chopping block.

Karen is next.

I agree that Karen and Naima are next to go. I only really like 3 or 4 of the singers this year.