NFP Sunday Blitz
A closer look at the Browns' big draft trade, impact assistant coaches and all the latest scuttlebutt.
Dan Pompei
May 15, 2011, 06:00 AM EST
New Browns coach Pat Shurmur, perhaps trying to get a group of Browns backers a little jacked up, called it “
The respected Tony Grossi of the Cleveland Plain Dealer questioned whether the Browns passed on a star to take a handful of ordinary Joes. Many Browns fans appeared to share his sentiment.
Both perspectives are interesting.
When you make a deal like the Browns did, moving down 21 spots and passing up a potential start like Julio Jones, you unquestionably leave yourself open to criticism. A couple of weeks ago, I examined why the Falcons felt compelled to make the deal. Now, I’d like to take you through the thought process on the other end of the telephone line.
First, understand the trade down was not about the Browns not liking Jones. If no deal had been offered, it’s very likely Jones would be house-hunting in the Cleveland area now. Browns general manager Tom Heckert told me he probably would have done the deal no matter who was left at 6, though my guess is if Marcel Dareus had been on the board, it would have given the Browns pause.
“I do think Julio Jones, or whoever we would have taken at 6, is going to be a really, really good player,” Heckert said. “We were more focused on getting more players. We knew we were more than just a couple guys away. The more picks we could get, the better off we could be.”
The Falcons thought one player could make a difference on their team. The Browns don’t have that feeling. They need numbers, and this gave them a chance to add numbers with the five draft picks (Phil Taylor after moving up, Greg Little, Owen Marecic and 2012 picks in the first and fourth rounds) they received for one.
Heckert was where the Falcons are now when he worked for the Eagles. Twice, he made draft trades from the other perspective in Philadelphia, moving up 12 spots for Shawn Andrews in 2004 and two spots for Jeremy Maclin in 2009. But this is different.
The chances of getting a star, as Grossi points out, are better the higher you pick. But there are a lot of disappointments at the top of the draft too. “You hope you get on a difference maker no matter where you are picking, but realistically, that’s probably not the way it’s going to be,” Heckert said. “We said let’s try to get to the point where Atlanta is so we could go out and get the one big time difference maker. We’re not there yet, and we thought that outweighed everything else. With more picks, you have more chances to get a difference maker, and if you get a bunch of good players, then you’re good.”
The Browns had numerous holes. Defensively, they were getting old. And they also are changing schemes, going from Eric Mangini’s 3-4 to Dick Jauron’s 4-3. They thought about sticking with a three man front just because of the personnel difficulties changing schemes can cause. This trade empowered them to make the switch because it resulted in the Browns getting two players who should be starters quickly in defensive tackle Taylor and defensive end in Jabaal Sheard.
“Defensive line was a big issue for us,” Heckert said. “We knew we were going to have to get them either through the draft or free agency or a combination, and that still could be the case. We still need a couple more guys.”
Part of the problem with making a deal like this is it doesn’t always go over well. Within an organization, there often are factions that are hoping for a star addition. And outside the organization, a move like this can be perceived as disheartening. Heckert said inside the building, everyone was on board. He knows the only way to win over Browns fans is to make sure the extra players they acquired develop into above average starters.
If the trade is all the Browns hope it could be, it will build the foundation of a contending team. Say this for the deal—given where the Browns are, the risk was worth the potential reward, and it followed sound logic.
“We’re in a rebuilding deal—the Falcons are not,” Heckert said. “I think it was a good move for both teams, I really do.”
http://www.nationalfootballpost.com/NFP-Sunday-Blitz-3468.html