Offensive Line
Since the arrival of Joe Thomas in 2007, the Browns’ offensive line has been never been more than two-thirds settled. While Thomas is one of the league’s best left tackles and Alex Mack has emerged as a top center, the Browns have continually had gaps at right guard and right tackle. Throw in Eric Steinbach’s advancing age and a case for the Browns’ management to focus on rebuilding the offensive line could be made.
Of course, under Heckert and Holmgren’s guidance, the Browns have both spent money and draft picks on the line – a virtual first for the team during the expansion age. However, 2010 free agent Tony Pashos has never fully recovered from a 2008 injury, while young talent Shaun Lauvao and Jason Pinkston are unproven.
Because of these investments, it’s likely that the Browns will again turn to patchwork measures – meaning that occasional 2010 starters Floyd Womack and Billy Yates could be targets. While Womack is serviceable in small doses, Yates proved to be surprisingly effective during his few 2010 starts and would make a valuable 2011 pickup. However, if the Browns want to make a bulky splash in free agency, Atlanta’s Tyson Clabo would fill the hole at right tackle that has loomed for over a decade.
However, a more modest version of Clabo could be found with Baltimore’s Marshal Yando. Yando manhandled the Browns twice last season and is versatile enough to play guard along with tackle. After Clabo and Yanda, there is a significant decline in available talent. Pittsburgh’s Willie Colon is returning after a 2010 injury, while Denver’s Ryan Harris could be an interesting option. Former St. Louis tackle Adam Goldberg could be some one-year gap filler, along with veteran Eagle Reggie Wells.
Running Back
The Browns’ 2011 running back situation shouldn’t be compared to the mess at linebacker, but is dangerously closer than most people probably think. Although Peyton Hillis at times appears to be superhuman, it’s unlikely that his bruising style will enable a fully healthy season. At times, Hillis will need to be relieved by other backs in order to preserve his body. Yet, Hillis’ primary backup is Montario Hardesty, who is literally another blown knee from football oblivion.
While Hillis’ injury concerns are more projected at this point in his career, it’s telling how much the Browns’ offensive production dropped late in 2010. With Hillis ailing, the Browns’ offense lost direction – much in the way that the 2011 season could follow suit. With these factors in mind – along with the idea that both Hillis and Hardesty have similar running styles – finding a free agent running back should be an ideal goal for the Browns.
There are some big name free agent backs available, including Carolina’s D’Angelo Williams, Miami’s Ronnie Brown and the Giants’ Ahmad Bradshaw. However, all three of these backs – and many more – will command extraordinary free agent money. In the Browns’ case, a lower-profile NFC West player such as Arizona’s Tim Hightower or former Ram Kenneth Darby could make sense. Of course, so would former Brown and Eagle Jerome Harrison. However, such a move will likely be determined based on Hardesty’s health and the prospects of which free agent back could play special teams.
Wide Receiver
Wide receiver is the most scandalous of free agent talk; yet for the Browns this position could prove to be of the least importance over the next couple weeks. Currently, the Browns feature two mini-waves of young receiver talent, in 2009’s Mohamed Massaquoi and Brian Robiskie, along with 2010 and 2011 rookies Carlton Mitchell and Greg Little. Despite the slight range of experience among all four players, still not much is known about any.
Massaquoi and Robiskie are getting a second chance as they should find more success in Shurmur’s receiver-friendly offense as compared to Brian Daboll’s physically challenging scheme. Mitchell and Little are unknown talents, but feature the kind of size and speed that are intriguing – especially to a new offensive minded head coach. In this sense, it’s worth asking whether Shurmur and Heckert decide to make a move to grab a top-flight wide receiver – or try to forge an identity with the available talent.
Given the inherently high-profile image of the position, there are some star-caliber wideouts available, including San Diego’s Vincent Jackson, Minnesota’s Sidney Rice and the Jets’ Santonio Holmes. Of course, with such name recognition, all three players will command huge free agent deals. On a slightly more moderate salary level, Malcolm Floyd, James Jones and Steve Breaston could be options. Or, from a Shurmur perspective, Ben Obomanu and Laurent Robinson could become the reliable targets needed to pull off a quick transition to a West Coast attack.
The Pick
Despite what appear to be glaring holes in the team’s roster, the Browns are probably about 3-5 players away from solidifying all starting positions – at least in preparation for the start of the 2011 season. Obviously, free safety, linebacker, offensive and defensive line depth are major needs. However, the extent to which the Browns become major free agent players will likely rely on how much the team needs to spend to satisfy salary cap demands.
Assuming that the Browns need to lay out upwards of 20 million dollars to reach required cap space, it’s possible that two big name free agents could put the team halfway towards its goal. Such a scenario could see an expensive pass rusher or wide receiver landing a 5-9 million dollar annual deal. Or a more conservative approach would net three to four serviceable veterans at 3-5 million dollars per year.
Yet, in an also realistic vision, the Browns could be operating from a near-default mode in terms of overall expectations. Because of the steep incline that has already been placed in front of the Browns, free agency could be viewed as a temporary means to an end, rather than a construct of roster building. In this sense, free agency would deliver the Browns a variety of what could be viewed as “leftover” players – or those who were untouched by the first wave of movement.
As of now, the only certainties are intrigue regarding veteran talent and volume in terms of undrafted free agents. In terms of actual financial value, the extraordinarily high number of undrafted free agents could go a long way towards solving the Browns’ immediate roster depth needs. Over the next few weeks, there will be a flood of activity involving players without the type of name recognition associated with the soon to be wealthy names previously mentioned.
And while the names will circulate and leap from roster to roster, one thing is abundantly clear throughout the coming process.
Money will be spent.
http://cle.scout.com/2/1089076.html