Is it time for private schools to have theyre own playoffs in football

Football 4,700 replies 72,972 views
I
I Am Ahab
Posts: 478
Nov 20, 2011 6:07pm
Idk, exactly how it works but I don't think it's any secret the private schools have some advantages when it comes to getting good football players, more so than publics getting players via OE.

However, this situation has always reminded me of the BoSox before they finally won the WS in '04. It used to annoy the heck out of me when those Boston fans would cry about the Yanks unfair advantage and they won because they just bought a good team every season.

Meanwhile teams like the D Backs, Marlins, Angels, etc were too busy beating the "unbeatable" Yankees to cry about how unfair the NYY advantage was.

In the end those are 16 17 n 18 year olds. No matter how much a team (private or public) resembles an all star team , they can and will be defeated.

Coldwater is a a perfect example of this. In '07 they took their hometown boys all the way across tbe state and beat a top 10 NATIONALLY RANKED Mooney team for a state title.

No reason any other school can't do the same. Rarely are one of these poor little us schools going to have to face a NATIONALLY RANKED team.
D
Dean Wormer
Posts: 333
Nov 20, 2011 6:10pm
skank;981302 wrote:Well, if Moeller brought in kids from Texas....And parts unknown, Iggy gets kids from Brecksville, Rocky River, Painsville, Oregon...We all know about the Youngstown area all star teams known as Mooney and Ursuline....But if Coldwater can win a couple of titles, everything is on the up and up....Then you're right.
Thank you. I love seeing you say that I am right. It has such a nice ring to it.
Mooney44Cards's avatar
Mooney44Cards
Posts: 2,754
Nov 20, 2011 6:11pm
skank;981316 wrote:Said the guy whose team benefits the most.
Ya and I'm sure Massillon fans were really hating the system back when they won the mythical state title every year.
D
Dean Wormer
Posts: 333
Nov 20, 2011 6:16pm
Mooney44Cards;981327 wrote:Ya and I'm sure Massillon fans were really hating the system back when they won the mythical state title every year.
Even I'm not old enough to remember those titles. The voters had to actually use the U.S. mail to send in their votes. The internet wasn't even thought of yet.
skank's avatar
skank
Posts: 6,543
Nov 20, 2011 6:27pm
Trust me ladies....With the way the system is set up today, where, for example, a parochial school coach can hold a combine to find the best local, (haha, I said LOCAL), talent. Or where a parochial school coach can hand deliver a scholarsh....er, I mean voucher to a "poor inner city" kids house, these days as we know them may soon be called the "MYTHICAL DAYS OF FOOTBALL".
skank's avatar
skank
Posts: 6,543
Nov 20, 2011 6:30pm
Mooney44Cards;981327 wrote:Ya and I'm sure Massillon fans were really hating the system back when they won the mythical state title every year.


You mean the system where McKinley had to sit out a football season due to "recruiting" kids? Today, coupled with McKinley becoming parochial of course, those would be called vouchers.
Mooney44Cards's avatar
Mooney44Cards
Posts: 2,754
Nov 20, 2011 6:31pm
skank;981347 wrote:Trust me ladies....With the way the system is set up today, where, for example, a parochial school coach can hold a combine to find the best local, (haha, I said LOCAL), talent. Or where a parochial school coach can hand deliver a scholarsh....er, I mean voucher to a "poor inner city" kids house, these days as we know them may soon be called the "MYTHICAL DAYS OF FOOTBALL".
Mythical as in Massillon fans will pretend this era is make-believe because they can't manage to win a REAL championship.
R
Rocket08
Posts: 645
Nov 20, 2011 6:32pm
Usually it's sad to see a grown man cry, but not when it's the princess

Enjoying your winter princess?

Keep whining, it brings a smile to our faces :rolleyes:
R
Rocket08
Posts: 645
Nov 20, 2011 6:33pm
skank;981347 wrote:Trust me ladies....With the way the system is set up today, where, for example, a parochial school coach can hold a combine to find the best local, (haha, I said LOCAL), talent. Or where a parochial school coach can hand deliver a scholarsh....er, I mean voucher to a "poor inner city" kids house, these days as we know them may soon be called the "MYTHICAL DAYS OF FOOTBALL".
Usually it's sad to see a grown man cry, but not when it's the princess

Enjoying your winter princess?

Keep whining, it brings a smile to our faces :rolleyes:
B
BlueJ
Posts: 81
Nov 20, 2011 6:35pm
Coldwater and Marion Local in the State Semis again.... what advantage do they have? If Publics and Privates were in different playoffs you never would have any of the DSJ/Marion Local classics over the past decade. What a shame that would have been.
R
Rocket08
Posts: 645
Nov 20, 2011 6:35pm
skank;981350 wrote:You mean the system where McKinley had to sit out a football season due to "recruiting" kids? Today, coupled with McKinley becoming parochial of course, those would be called vouchers.
You, of coarse mean, where Massillon had to sit out a year

Not many can match that, cheater
R
Rocket08
Posts: 645
Nov 20, 2011 6:36pm
BlueJ;981360 wrote:Coldwater and Marion Local in the State Semis again.... what advantage do they have? If Publics and Privates were in different playoffs you never would have any of the DSJ/Marion Local classics over the past decade. What a shame that would have been.
He doesn't care one bit. If his cheating institution is left out, something must be wrong with the system
skank's avatar
skank
Posts: 6,543
Nov 20, 2011 6:37pm
Just keep recruiting the good ones boys.


If you have them, (vouchers), they will come. Aw, who am I kidding, even if you don't have them, you'll just go out and get em.
skank's avatar
skank
Posts: 6,543
Nov 20, 2011 6:39pm
Rocket08;981361 wrote:You, of coarse mean, where Massillon had to sit out a year

Not many can match that, cheater


Of course not, not when recruiting is legalized for the privates. And furthermore, if you don't understand the situation of which I speak, please refrain from commenting.
R
Rocket08
Posts: 645
Nov 20, 2011 6:40pm
Mooney44Cards;981351 wrote:Mythical as in Massillon fans will pretend this era is make-believe because they can't manage to win a REAL championship.
You gotta laugh when skank brings the word "mythical" up

He's gotta be the most frustrated little guy in the world

Enjoy the semi's this week princess, and next week should be great for you with all 6 State Championship games on TV.

Too bad D3 is in Canton though, I doubt if your mommy will let you out of school to go watch other teams actually win State Championships
R
Rocket08
Posts: 645
Nov 20, 2011 6:41pm
Maybe they'll come when your school actually graduates students that can read.

But Massillon wouldn't know a whole lot about that
skank's avatar
skank
Posts: 6,543
Nov 20, 2011 6:41pm
Rocket08;981363 wrote:He doesn't care one bit. If his cheating institution is left out, something must be wrong with the system


You mean as opposed to YOUR cheating institution?
R
Rocket08
Posts: 645
Nov 20, 2011 6:42pm
skank;981366 wrote:Of course not, not when recruiting is legalized for the privates. And furthermore, if you don't understand the situation of which I speak, please refrain from commenting.
Once again princess, how many players from McKinley system play for you?

Hypocrite
R
Rocket08
Posts: 645
Nov 20, 2011 6:43pm
skank;981373 wrote:You mean as opposed to YOUR cheating institution?
Man, you are the master of the come back :laugh:
Mooney44Cards's avatar
Mooney44Cards
Posts: 2,754
Nov 20, 2011 6:43pm
Rocket08;981368 wrote:You gotta laugh when skank brings the word "mythical" up

He's gotta be the most frustrated little guy in the world

Enjoy the semi's this week princess, and next week should be great for you with all 6 State Championship games on TV.

Too bad D3 is in Canton though, I doubt if your mommy will let you out of school to go watch other teams actually win State Championships
No no, he's the 40 year old guy wearing his Massillon letterman jacket that waves you into the Paul Brown Tiger Stadium parking lot with that bright orange flag on championship Friday. I've seen him several times the past few years.
skank's avatar
skank
Posts: 6,543
Nov 20, 2011 6:44pm
Rocket08;981368 wrote:You gotta laugh when skank brings the word "mythical" up

He's gotta be the most frustrated little guy in the world

Enjoy the semi's this week princess, and next week should be great for you with all 6 State Championship games on TV.

Too bad D3 is in Canton though, I doubt if your mommy will let you out of school to go watch other teams actually win State Championships


If you look just a little closer, you'll see that your pal brought up the word mythical, not me. but facts don't sit well with you do they?
skank's avatar
skank
Posts: 6,543
Nov 20, 2011 6:45pm
Rocket08;981372 wrote:Maybe they'll come when your school actually graduates students that can read.

But Massillon wouldn't know a whole lot about that


Said the guy who claims to be an English major, yet doesn't know how to use punctuation.
Mooney44Cards's avatar
Mooney44Cards
Posts: 2,754
Nov 20, 2011 6:47pm
skank;981380 wrote:Said the guy who claims to be an English major, yet doesn't know how to use punctuation.
Choosing not to use it = not knowing how

K, got it.
skank's avatar
skank
Posts: 6,543
Nov 20, 2011 6:48pm
Mooney44Cards;981377 wrote:No no, he's the 40 year old guy wearing his Massillon letterman jacket that waves you into the Paul Brown Tiger Stadium parking lot with that bright orange flag on championship Friday. I've seen him several times the past few years.


Yeah, maybe I should quit parking cars and hit the recruiting trail like you and, "the English Major".
skank's avatar
skank
Posts: 6,543
Nov 20, 2011 6:50pm
Mooney44Cards;981382 wrote:Choosing not to use it = not knowing how

K, got it.


Ok, I wasn't really talking about you, but now that you mention it....Don't tell me we have ANOTHER English Major.