Commander of Awesome;1303430 wrote:LMAO, nice fail by judging if a book is good or not depending on the movie. Great Gatsby is a classic, and a great piece of literature. Nice fail.
Also, the movie looks horrendous, and obv strays from the book.
I just came back to this thread and saw your post. I'm not sure I follow you. Are you saying that your impression is that I disliked
The Great Gatsby movie and thus determined that the book was bad? I thought it was pretty clear from my previous post that (1) I read the book, and while I thought it was fine, it's not the great piece of AmLit it's made out to be, and (2) it'll be interesting to see if the movie is any better this time around.
Nice fail.
If I were picking my favorite AmLit, it'd be something like (1) The Poisonwood Bible, (2) Of Mice and Men, (3) Huck Finn, (4) Slaughterhouse-Five, and (5) The Catcher in the Rye. The Great Gatsby is a good book, like I said, but I don't understand why people act like it's the most amazing piece of literature ever written.