I’d likely sit and watch a blank tv f given the choice

I plan to watch tomorrow. I dig some of the rule changes.

Saw an advertisement a few weeks ago where they promoted some of their QBs like Connor Cook and Cardale Jones. It’s a bold strategy considering no one was turning on the TV to watch them in NFL, so why would they now?

i didn’t know when it was starting up but I’m surprised it’s the weekend right after the Super Bowl. 

People just don’t want to watch players who failed at the highest level. The best shot of a league like this working is the G-League after the HS are allowed back in the draft. Bring foreign players around quicker vs stashing in Europe and have a system similar to MLB. Service time doesn’t start until 30 games in a season or something.
 

But if fans can watch young players who MAY someday help their squad at the highest level, you have a chance. To ask fans to tune in to watch players who couldn’t make it at the highest level is a strategy doomed to fail.

posted by Laley23

People just don’t want to watch players who failed at the highest level.
To ask fans to tune in to watch players who couldn’t make it at the highest level is a strategy doomed to fail.

And I will not be following. 

I’m watching. What else is there to watch in February? It actually hasn’t been that bad. It’ll be interesting to see how long it can survive. 

I have to go run a few errands soon, otherwise I'd keep watching. It's been entertaining enough. I don't like the immediate interviews after big plays, though.

Dude nailed a 55 yard field goal to end the first half. 

I might follow Landry Jones just to laugh at the fact he's better than either back-up PIT rolled into 2019 with....

I'm a big fan of the kickoff rules. I hope that experiment makes it into the NFL soon.

Appears to be a quality product

I have liked it so far.  The KO rule is genius. It will force more returns and I think less injuries and penalities.

Play has not been bad.   The issue they will have and there is no way around it.....and that I our emotional attachment to the teams.  Some players from your college but that won't sustain fandom    so much of sports is how much emotional attachments we have to the team, college, players over decades and that just won't happen here.  I think it will serve a good purpose and rigjt after NFL season is good lead in    plus having fox and ESPN on board helps and I hope this works and becomes associated with the NFL as a minor league

The Houston QB was fun to watch.

Watched most of the LA-HOUSTON game. Liked pretty much all of it, kick off and punt rules, the ready for play official with the extra ball, TV viewers "in on the play call", sideline interviews........and for a Game #1 the quality of play was decent. I've seen a lot worse professional football. 

McGloin is awful

Cardale looking like MVP and a training camp this summer

I'm thinkinh Seattle could get 20k for a pee wee game.  Their crowd was crazy.   Best case scenario is a number of guys get an invite in the NFL and isn't there one player who played this college season and left school/ grades and is playing an expected to get drafted?

Landry Jones is terrible!

First XFL game I've watched (DAL-LA), and I would not say the football has been good.

The ending of DAL and LA wasn't bad. Lots of scoring late. But it was rough for the first 3 quarters. The offenses were moving the ball a little bit, but just couldn't score.

Need more first half scoring which this late game has a little.   A lot of rusty offense, and coaches not quite knowing yet what they're players can and cannot do well.   Entertaining enough for me to keep watching.

Watching LA vs NY currently. Anyone else tuned in? 

First big flaw in the kickoff rule exposed. Return team was penalized on the previous field goal and the penalty was assessed on the kickoff. But, a touchback punishes the kicking team severely. 

Decent game so far. I’m impressed by the officiating so far in pretty much every game I’ve watched. 

posted by justincredible

Decent game so far. I’m impressed by the officiating so far in pretty much every game I’ve watched. 

Sonofanump'd.

posted by justincredible

First big flaw in the kickoff rule exposed. Return team was penalized on the previous field goal and the penalty was assessed on the kickoff. But, a touchback punishes the kicking team severely. 

IF the kicking team can't refuse the penalty I'd like to see the XFL get creative with the rule.

For instance, Let's say that it was a 10 yard penalty. Have the kickoff from the regular spot, then enforce that penalty after the return. If the return went to the 50, back it to the 40 for a 1st and 10....or leave it at the 50 for a 1st and 20. If the return went for a TD, too bad.....it's 1st and Goal at the 10.

End of Rant.

I think that’s the easiest solution. Enforce it on the result of the return. 
 

Some rules guy tried explaining the strategy for the kicking team as it was happening, because the guys on the both were questioning how it’s actually penalizing the return team, and he really had no good answer.