Private, both elementary and hs--and we sent our kids to both as well. Our main reason, of course, was that we felt that since we lived in Toledo (and not a suburb), they would get a better education, because, well...TPS sucks.
That being said, we here in the Toledo area have wonderful public schools in Perrysburg, Maumee, Anthony Wayne, Sylvania, etc, so that could've have been an option had we lived in one of these towns.